AITAH for letting my best friend (of 25 years) to live with me for 3 months and then said I kicked her out after 4 weeks?

She opened her home rent free to her best friend of 25 years after a breakup. Weeks later, that friend was telling everyone a very different story about it.

2 min 1 0
AITAH for letting my best friend (of 25 years) to live with me for 3 months and then said I kicked her out after 4 weeks?

When a friend’s life falls apart, offering them a place to stay feels like the most natural thing in the world. One woman did exactly that for her best friend of twenty-five years, rent free and with open arms. But as the weeks passed, the houseguest she loved became someone she barely recognized, and the story she tells now is not the one their friends are hearing.

AITAH for letting my best friend (of 25 years) to live with me for 3 months and then said I kicked her out after 4 weeks? - My (30F) best friend (Jen 30F) broke up with her partner of five years. They were living together in a 2 bed flat and they were stuck in a three year tenancy. I told Jen that she could live with me and my husband for 3 months, rent free and only contributing $50 to the weekly food shop (no other bills). The first few weeks were absolutely fine. We had a great time and then things started to take a turn.. She kept asking me to tell my husband to be quiet in his own house (e.g. 9 pm on a
weekday or 11 pm on his birthday weekend). When I wouldn’t tell him to be quiet, she would throw a tantrum and make the environment very hostile, ice me out etc. I felt like I was walking on eggshells in my own house. Then Jen started doing other things like inviting her brother to stay at my house for a week, when me and my husband were on holiday… I tried to talk to her, told her I love her but we needed to talk because the environment hasn’t been feeling comfortable for us. I also asked her whether she’s still on track to move out in 2 months (because I saw no effort). The conversation upset her, she said she’s still stuck in her tenancy and she might be stuck in it for

What began as cozy evenings and good company slowly changed into tension at every turn. Soon she was tiptoeing around her own home, and her friend’s demands kept growing in ways she never expected.

another two years and she won’t be able to pay rent in two different places… Even though she has $40,000 of savings in her bank. For context, her savings were a payout from a work issue, which she wasn’t going to pursue but I made her do it. She then said she’s not gonna contribute to the food shop anymore, because she can’t afford it and is going to stay out of the house. Started buying her own food but still eating ours… I sat her down again, told her we need to figure this out because I’m feeling uncomfortable and this can’t go on for another 2 months. In the same conversation she said she’s

Her friend’s money was only part of the story. As the weeks dragged on, the tension spilled into the kitchen, and another sit-down conversation brought a surprise move-out plan she never saw coming.

going to move out at the end of the week and live with her grandparents (news to me that was an option). She just liked my house more and it was more convenient. I agreed that was the best idea for our friendship and I even helped her move to her grandparents apartment. I actually thought the conversation went pretty well and it was really mature… but boy was I wrong. A few weeks later, she lets me know she’s not over the whole situation. That I completely wronged her. If the tables were turned she would have let me stay her house indefinitely. Which is not true, she’s extremely uptight and would have given me a strict deadline.

Helping her friend move felt like a happy ending for both of them. But a few weeks later, a message arrived that made it clear her friend saw the whole thing very differently.

She probably wouldn’t have let me stay for longer than a few weeks tbh. I told her I was sorry to hear that, but let’s talk about it. I told her I never agreed to let her stay indefinitely. That I can’t afford to cover her rent/bills for longer than a couple months. And I told her, whilst we’re back on the topic, I didn’t mention this before but I felt she was behaving entitled and ungrateful. But we’re practically like sisters at this point and we can work through this. In the meantime, she was lying to our mutual friends behind my back. Saying I kicked her out of the house after 4 weeks. Not true. That she was asking my husband to be quiet at like 2 am

She hoped honesty would bring them closer again, but word reached her about what was being said behind her back. The version spreading through their friend group was very different from what really happened.

on a weekday. Not true and texts to prove it. That she did all the cleaning at my house and my husband didn’t do any. Again not true and why is my poor husband catching strays? Once I heard she was lying to our mutual friends, I felt angry and upset. I needed some space (I told her this). She took that as me trying to punish her because she wanted to talk about it immediately. Some more bad timing.. A few days later, I messaged her to say we should clear the air. Because we’re seeing our group of friends at the end of the week and we don’t want make things uncomfortable for them. She said she doesn’t want to talk, now that it’s on my terms?? Huh
okay.. We met our friends, saw each other, I looked at her to say hi and she turned her head and ignored me for the whole day. I messaged her and said when she’s ready, we can talk about it all. Her response was, she’s going through a lot with her break up and moving, so she wants to leave the friendship where it is. We haven’t spoken since. More things happened but I’m trying to keep it short (if you could believe it LOL). Our mutuals are trying to stay out of it and trying to remain neutral. Idk how I feel about that at times. They’ve also said they

Trying to make peace in front of their friends did not go to plan. As the days passed, the silence grew heavier, and the people caught in the middle had their own thoughts about who was really at fault.

know what she’s like and I’ve always been a crutch for her. She’s generally made things uncomfortable for our mutual friends too, because they’re still friends with me. Shes left the group chat and distanced herself. But still make an effort with them every now and then. I feel sad sometimes, we had so many good times over the last 25 years and I really thought she would always be in my life. Feels strange. Anyway if you’ve made it this far.. you’re a trooper and I thank you! TLDR: I let my best friend, live with me and my husband rent free, after her breakup. She started acting weird. I spoke

After all the drama, what remains is a quiet sadness. Twenty-five years of memories do not disappear overnight, and she is left wondering how a friendship that once felt like sisterhood could end this way.

with her, she moved to her grandparents. She told our mutual friends I kicked her out and other lies. We haven’t spoken since. Our friends have remained neutral. I’m sad I’ve lost a longstanding friendship.

So, Did She Do the Right Thing?

Breakups are brutal, and her friend may have felt abandoned at a vulnerable time. But three months rent free was generous, and the stories spreading around were simply not what happened. Redditors were clear that she was not in the wrong, praising her kindness and wondering why their friends stayed neutral. Would you have handled it the same way? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/moewthug on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *