AITA for telling my grandpa his “reward” system is hurtful?

His cousins got free car repairs at Grandpa's garage while he paid full price. When he found out why, he spoke up, and the whole family turned on him.

2 min 0
AITA for telling my grandpa his “reward” system is hurtful?

Family businesses come with family perks, or at least they are supposed to. When a 20-year-old university student learned that his cousins had been getting free repairs at their grandfather’s garage while he kept paying full price, he assumed it was simple luck. The real reason turned out to be far more personal, and asking about it split the whole family.

AITA for telling my grandpa his “reward” system is hurtful? - I (20M) went to a family party last week, and while I was talking with my cousins, they mentioned how fun it was that they never had to pay for their oil changes and other small maintenance or repairs on their car. I wasn’t surprised, because my grandfather owns a garage and all the family heads over to get their car fixed there when they need to. I’ve always had to pay my grandfather, but I hadn’t been there in a few months, so I assumed business WAW going well and he recently could afford to discount family. A few days later, I head there for an oil change, come back an hour later,
and thank my grandfather with a pack of beer, he laughs and says that’s not how it works here and that while it’s a nice gesture i’m still gonna have to pay up. I didn’t say much and handed him the money. I later talked to my grandmother about it and asked her why my cousins get it for free but I still have to pay. She tells me it’s based on how much "effort" we put into our lives. Some of my cousins have very good jobs, accountants and police work ect, those cousins get their car fixes for free, meanwhile I’m still knees deep in my uni studies, my cousin had accidentally had a kid very young and is trying to get his life back together and one of my siblings has a minimal study trade job, so

He paid without a fuss, but the moment stayed with him. Something did not add up, so he went to the one person in the family who always seemed to know how things really worked behind the scenes: his grandmother. Her answer was not what he expected.

Learning that his grandfather was quietly ranking the grandchildren by success stung far more than any oil change bill. Instead of letting it slide, he decided to bring it up with the man himself, and the conversation went downhill very quickly.

we don’t get our car fixes for free because we didn’t work enough to deserve it according to him. I addressed this with him, and he blew up at me, saying that nobody gets their car fixed for free anyway, that it’s not like he’s taking anything away from me or some of my cousins, but that he does reward those who put effort into being successful. Now a bunch of my family is mad at me for starting an argument with my grandfather over this.. AITA?

So, Was He Wrong to Speak Up?

It is the grandfather’s garage, and nobody is owed free work. Still, rewarding the grandkids who need help the least while charging the student, the young parent and the sibling in a modest trade feels less like a reward system and more like favouritism. Redditors overwhelmingly sided with the grandson, many suggesting he simply take his car elsewhere. Was he right to call it hurtful, or should he have kept quiet? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Weekly-Ear8492 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *