AITA for referring to myself as a lone twin?

A teen who lost her twin sister as a newborn calls herself a lone twin, but a friend says she has no right to the label because she never knew her.

1 min 0
AITA for referring to myself as a lone twin?

A teenage girl has spent years quietly thinking about the twin sister she never got to know. When she finally decided to speak her sister’s name out loud among friends, one friend’s reaction cut deeper than she could have imagined, and left her questioning the very words she uses to describe herself.

AITA for referring to myself as a lone twin? - I, 17 female, had a twin sister. Maggie. I say had because she died of a brain illness a week after being born. I too had medical issues, however there was surgery available for my medical issues and not hers. So while I obviously never had any conversations with her, and I don’t remember her, she is still my twin. And I’m sure she would be bright and kind and loving, as my sister and I are. I think about her quite often. And wonder if I’m really a twin-less twin or not, since I never really knew her. However I’ve recently decided that if I never mention her it’s as if she never existed. And that’s not fair to her.

Determined to keep her sister’s memory alive, she started mentioning her more openly. It seemed like such a small, gentle step, until a casual chat about siblings with her friends turned into something far more painful.

Anyways, the problem came to be when me and my friends got to talking about siblings. I have one older sister. So I mentioned her, and that I was a lone twin. My friend, who knew about her, said that it was disrespectful to call myself a lone twin because I “never knew her” and it’s disrespectful to people who have “actually lost twins”. I got really upset and started crying. I excused myself to the bathroom and spent the rest of free period there. So my question is, am I the a**hole? Should I be using a different label? Edit: I’ve had some people ask, my friend is not a twin. She has two sister. But neither are a twin. Also, I wanna thank everyone for all of the kind replies

So, Is She Allowed to Call Herself a Lone Twin?

Her friend may have believed she was standing up for others who have lost a twin later in life, and grief can make people protective of words. But Redditors were close to unanimous: they told this young woman she lost her sister, that lone twin and twinless twin are widely used terms, and that nobody else gets to rank her grief. Many sent her warm messages too. How would you have responded to that friend? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Final_Photograph6687 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *