AITAH for telling my mother we’re not bringing my daughter to her house anymore

His mother brought home a powerful guard dog after everyone urged a smaller breed. Now he won't bring his 3-year-old there, and she says it will all be fine.

2 min 1 0
AITAH for telling my mother we’re not bringing my daughter to her house anymore

Grandparents and grandkids usually go together like cookies and milk, but one dad has drawn a firm line around his mother’s front door. After a string of surprising decisions, she brought home a dog that worries him deeply. He has made his position clear, and now he is asking whether he is protecting his daughter or simply looking for a reason to keep his distance.

AITAH for telling my mother we’re not bringing my daughter to her house anymore - 37M here. I have a 3 year old daughter with my girlfriend of 6 years. My mother is an odd one. Somewhat bipolar. Today she’s hunky dory and tomorrow she’ll be texting me telling me that I don’t care about anyone but myself when I didn’t answer her text in the middle of a work day. Ever since she left my step dad after 25 years, she’s been on an emotional fulfillment journey and apparently, her three sons are the only ones who can do that, but only when she needs it. And God forbid we don’t answer her on those days. My mother decided to move 45 minutes
away when she used to be about 10 minutes away. She never told me that she was buying the house because she knew I was going to tell her it was a bad idea. And guess what, she can’t manage it. Gets stuck in her driveway, refuses to mow because it’s too much, has a mold issue and hasn’t touched it, can’t afford the mortgage because she quit her high paying job right after she bought the house cuz she didn’t want to commute. So my brother gives her money now. We have 3 kids in our house, full time jobs and constant projects going on. We invite her over whenever as she lives alone. We do make the trip out there but our daughter throws up almost

Moving farther away was only the beginning. As he explains, the new house came with problems of its own, and the growing distance set the stage for a decision that would test the whole family.

every time so it’s not something we’re pumped to do. So being that my mother says I’m too busy for her, she decided to look into getting a dog. My brother texts me and says it’s a cane corso. Mind you, this woman is not strong, she falls down stairs before she even gets to them and has never owned her own animal ever. So my initial reaction is to have a calm and supportive conversation to persuade her into a smaller, more manageable animal. I mentioned that if that dog decided to not listen, that’s all it’s gonna take. Those dogs are naturally protective and I didn’t feel comfortable bringing my daughter around a strange dog because my daughter can be a

Getting a pet to ease the loneliness sounds harmless enough. But when his brother revealed which breed she had in mind, alarm bells started ringing, especially for a dad with a curious little girl at home.

bit aggressive with our dog, but they’ve grown up together and my dog is used to her. I know cane corsos can be gentle giants but I’m not willing to take any risk. Mom starts going on about how it’s the only dog she’s ever wanted and everyone’s always told her no, mind you, this is the first any of us are hearing about this. She’s told us plenty of times she wanted an older hound dog because she spent have time for a puppy. So, I tell her again, if you get this dog, I’m not bringing my daughter to your house, you’ll have to come out here if you want to see her. She said it’ll be ok and it’ll all be fine. Ok. Long story short, she gets the dog.

He made his worries clear and hoped she would reconsider. But his mother had a surprising answer ready, one none of her sons had ever heard before, and she was not budging.

After countless talks and discussions and browsing for other dogs. Moms lonely, doesn’t want a human companion, wants a dog. Side note, this is the same lady who volunteered to watch my dogs when I went on a weekend vacation, took them to her house, texted me that night telling me how great they were, I suggested she crate the one dog at night because it likes to pee in the house at night. Next day, I get a crying phone call saying she couldn’t watch my dogs when I’m 6 hours away because they peed in her house and they don’t listen, so she just dropped them off at my house and I had to have my neighbor and some friends come check on them for

Before making up your mind, there is a little history worth knowing. Not long ago, his mother had offered to watch his own dogs for a weekend, and the way that ended still shapes how he sees her plans now.

another day. I go over to get something from her house and she immediately crates the dog, as it’s not happy to see me at all. Of course, I’m a stranger, this dog thinks it’s just them. Mom tells me I’m not to make eye contact with this dog, I have to approach cautiously and it takes time for it to acclimate. This is a 2 year old dog. The exact opposite of what all of us remember her telling us, but apparently we weren’t listening when she told us she wanted cane corso. I’d never heard of that breed up until my brother told me. There is so much more to this story, I could go on for days but AITAH for not wanting to bring

Those cautious rules only made him more uneasy. And once his story drew a crowd of readers, a few of his own words were picked apart, so he returned to explain what he really meant about his daughter and his dog.

my daughter around this dog? Or is it my mother and I’m just using the dog as an excuse. EDIT: For those of you focusing on me saying my daughter is aggressive with our dog, what I mean by that is that they grew up together and she understands what my dog tolerates and what she doesn’t. My dog and daughter are two peas. My daughter is aware that she can’t just approach random dogs without caution. What I am saying is I don’t trust untrained animals with untrained owners. ANOTHER EDIT: For those of you focusing on the mold portion of the story, I didn’t have it tested but it’s in a damp part of a basement and looks like mold on the floor joists and insulation. We

One more detail drew a lot of attention, and it had nothing to do with the dog. He returned once again to clear up what people were assuming about his mother’s basement and his daughter’s carsickness.

haven’t been there since so I couldn’t tell you with any certainty if she took care of it or not. I wasn’t knowingly taking my family in a moldy house. My daughter gets sick from long car rides. It’s been a thing since day 1.

So, Is He Being Overprotective?

His mother is lonely and clearly loves the dog she always wanted, and keeping her granddaughter away may feel like a punishment to her. But he set his condition before she adopted, and she can still visit them anytime. Redditors broadly backed him, saying safety comes first with a powerful dog and an inexperienced owner, while a few urged him to keep teaching his toddler gentle habits too. What is your verdict? Tell us in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Primary_Ad4909 on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *