AITAH for not accepting my girlfriend’s apology?

After five years, his girlfriend proved she barely knew his interests. Her apology came with a twist that blamed him. Was he wrong to reject it?

2 min 0
AITAH for not accepting my girlfriend’s apology?

Five years together, few fights and plenty of good memories. On paper, this couple seemed solid. But one young man had been quietly swallowing a hurt that grew with every passing year, until one evening with friends made it impossible to ignore. When his girlfriend finally apologized, he did something many would not expect: he refused to accept it.

AITAH for not accepting my girlfriend’s apology? - Hello. I (24M) have been dating my girlfriend (24F) for almost 5 years. We get along generally well, and the times we've fought are few and far between. That's not to mean it has been a perfect relationship. I've had to deal with some coldness and apathy from her from time to time, but the good moments outweigh the bad ones. To give some background, I'm a pretty nerdy guy, she's more culturally inclinded. I like videogames, anime, etc. She likes ballet, actively participates in our country's folklore, as well as other things. As a boyfriend, I've always tried my best to enjoy the things she enjoys. I've
accompanied her to ballet recitals, I've accompanied her to see movies about books she enjoys, I've gone with her to the countryside, I've listened with her the music she likes, among others. They may not be my cup of tea, but I enjoy seeing her enjoy herself, and I'm happy I can enjoy myself with the things she enjoys. The same can't be said about her towards me, and that's the entire origin of this issue. I've tried to introduce her to the stuff I like, only to be met with apathy. If I'm playing a game that looks odd to her, she'll throw a snide comment about it. She's insulted my hobbies many times throughout our relationship and has not partaken in them. I've

He had gone out of his way to embrace her world, from ballet recitals to countryside trips. Naturally, he hoped she might show a little curiosity about his. What he got instead slowly changed the way he talked to her about the things he loved.

tried introducing them to her, but it's never worked. The constant insults and apathy resulted in me closing myself off about my hobbies. I stopped talking about what I liked, and the very few times she has asked what was I up to, I always gave her the most superficial, barebones responses (If I'm playing games, I'd just say I'm watching TV, for example). That's not to say I was happy with that. But in my head I figured that was all something I had to deal with. That I had to focus on being the best boyfriend I could be, while keeping my hobbies to myself and among my friends that share them. But things came to a climax recently.

Keeping his passions to himself felt like a small price to pay for a peaceful relationship. He told himself it was simply part of the deal. Then came a moment in front of their whole friend group that stripped away that comforting story.

I'll save you the details of how it happened (I'd be happy to give them if it's determined to be important context), but the point is that it was proven definitively in front of me and our friend group that after almost 5 years of relationship, she doesn't know me at all. I expected it to be that way, but having it confirmed in front of everyone was a kick to the balls. On the ride back home, I finally spoke out about what I felt. I told her I was dissapointed in how little she knows about me. I've asked her about her hobbies before, so I could answer very easily the same questions she failed. The rest of the car ride home was silent.

The silent ride home was only the beginning. After a birthday spent avoiding the subject, he finally sat down and poured everything into one long, honest message, hoping this third attempt at the conversation would be the one that finally got through.

The next day was my birthday. I told her I didn't want to talk about it that day. That we would talk later. And today was the later. I messaged her with pretty much all the details I've given here, added with specific examples of the times she has insulted my hobbies, how it made me feel, how it's very sad that we're in this position, and that this has been going for 5 years. It's important to note this is the third time I've talked to her about this topic. All I needed from her was her willingness to ask. I don't care if she ends up not enjoying the same stuff I do, I don't expect her to. I just wish she'd at least act interested. And I thought it was all good: she said she was

At first, it seemed his words had landed and that an apology had settled everything. But almost in the same breath, his girlfriend offered an explanation that turned the whole conversation upside down and left him wondering whether she had heard him at all.

sorry for everything. And right after that she dropped the most ridiculous thing she has ever said. She said that me not talking to her about my hobbies after she insulted them (which she framed as being curious about them) is MY fault. And that I should've approached her with them. I told her I did, and when I did she was apathetic or insulted my hobbies, and that's the reason why I stopped. She completely glossed over that, and proceeded to say that either way she was sorry for everything... for both the things that were fault and the things that were my fault.

Her twist on responsibility left him stunned, and he did not hold back his frustration. As the exchange grew more heated, it became clear the two of them had completely different ideas about what a real apology should look like.

I was floored. I asked her what the hell she meant the things that were my fault? It's not like I avoided talking about my hobbies because I wanted to. She said that it was okay and that she was willing to assume responsibility for that, even if it was my fault. I told her she's being ridiculous. That her apologizing for everything is worthless if she doesn't really feel sorry for everything. I told her that I wasn't looking for an apology by me telling her everything, I just wanted her to understand where I was coming from, and hopefully change. I said she was just apologizing to get it over with.

The argument ended with her going to bed angry and him lying awake, replaying every word. Determined to be fair, he decided to put his side to a crowd of strangers and ask whether he was the one being unreasonable.

She told me I was wrong. In her mind, she somehow believed that her apologizing about what she did wrong and assuming responsibility for what I supposedly did wrong was some sort of grand gesture. I told her I was way more dissapointed in her response than in the reason we had the conversation in the first place. She got p**sed and went to sleep. Honestly, I don't think I'm in the wrong here. Whenever I have done wrong, I have assumed ny responsibility without ifs and buts. I know when I f**k up. And I don't think this was one of them.
But I'm here asking internet strangers for help, because there is always the chance I AM wrong. I'm happy to provide any details that the court of public opinion deems necessary for judgement. So, am I the AH for not accepting my girlfriend's apology?

So, Should He Have Accepted the Apology?

An apology is still an olive branch, and some would argue he could have taken it and worked on the rest over time. Yet an apology that shifts blame back onto him can feel more like a deflection than a sincere effort to change. Most Redditors sided with him, though many gently questioned whether a relationship this one-sided is worth continuing at all. Do you think he was right to push back? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/LaziestOnTheJob on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *