AITA for not baking for my roomate when guests are over?

He left a fresh apple crumble and cookies for his roommate's party, but instead of thanks, she told him it simply wasn't enough for her guests.

1 min 0
AITA for not baking for my roomate when guests are over?

For one 22-year-old, baking is more than a hobby. It is how he unwinds, how he copes with stress, and how he shows kindness to the people around him. So when he left a warm apple crumble and a batch of cookies out for his roommate’s party, he thought he was being generous. His roommate had a very different idea of what generous looks like.

AITA for not baking for my roomate when guests are over? - I, 22 male have a passion and hobby for baking. I bake whenever I have time. It has been this way since I was about fourteen. My roomate who we will call "Layla" for privacy loves partying, which i dont really have a problem with. I let her have guests when I am out. I personally have really bad anxiety with loud noises so I think it is fair when she parties while I am out. Though, as of late. I have been baking more due to stress on personals reasons. And for a small clarification, I am more than happy to share my treats with my roomates and other people if
there are much left. A few nights ago, my roomate hosted another one of her parties. I baked earlier that day, so i left apple crumble and one batch of cookies for her and anyone else who might come.I came home after a long night shift, and Layla seemed to be more distant. Naturally, I was confused. But I assumed she might be tired from all the partying. So I got myself ready for bed myself. I went to the kitchen to grab myself an apple just for a snack and layla was making herself some tea. She cleared her throat to get my attention and said she was upset with me, that I baked so little for her and her guests. I was tired and confused. So I asked her what she meant. And she said

He came home exhausted from a night shift, expecting nothing more than a quiet snack and his bed. Instead, he walked into a chilly atmosphere and a roommate who clearly had something on her mind, and it was about to involve his oven.

that the apple crumble and batch of cookies werent enough and that I should bake more when guests are over. Now here's where I might be the jerk. I told her that I couldn't whip up a feast of sweets when she wants me to. Everything takes alot of time to make, and costs alot. After I told her that, she seemed visibly upset and walked off. But now im in my room wondering if I were too harsh.AITA? Also, please forgive any spelling mistakes. English is not my first language

So, Was He Wrong to Say No?

It is easy to see why the roommate might have wanted a bigger spread for her friends, but nobody signed him up as the house caterer. He shared his treats freely, after a long shift, using his own time and money. Redditors were overwhelmingly on his side, saying he was not in the wrong and that her guests are hers to feed. Do you think he was too blunt, or was the complaint simply ungrateful? Share your verdict in the comments!

Source: This story was originally shared by u/NOISLAYER on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *