AITA for telling my parents their kids aren’t mine.

Her parents expect her to make food for her 14 and 11-year-old siblings every time she eats. When she said they are not her kids, it blew up.

1 min 0
AITA for telling my parents their kids aren’t mine.

Being the oldest sibling often comes with unspoken duties. A 19-year-old raised on the idea of being her siblings’ keeper has spent years making extra breakfasts and buying extra snacks for her two younger siblings. Now that they are 14 and 11, she thinks they can ask for themselves. Her parents strongly disagree, and one blunt sentence made things worse.

AITA for telling my parents their kids aren’t mine. - Okay so I 19 female am the oldest child in my family. Both my parents are older siblings themselves who more or less raised their younger siblings. So needless to say I was raised on a very strict “you are your siblings keeper” type program, now luckily my parents didn’t parentify me. They’re definitely here for my siblings so you’d assume all would be well right? No. My parents are the type to believe I should always keep them in mind. When I make breakfast for myself, I need to make some for them. When I buy food for myself, I need to buy some for them too. We have
gotten into many disagreements about this. Even though I disagreed I could at least see the logic when my siblings were younger and physically couldn’t do things for themselves but now things are different. One of my siblings are 14 the other is 11. At those ages I could do things that they simply just can’t or just won’t do. So recently we got into an argument about this and I said, “if my siblings just ask me I’ll do it, but what I’m not gonna do is chase them down to ask if THEY want something. They’re big kids, if they’re wanting, they need to ask or learn to do it themselves.” This went over terribly. They said I was their older sister and I needed to take care of them and

The arrangement made sense when her siblings were small. Now they are old enough to make a sandwich, yet the expectation has not changed. When the topic came up again, she drew a line, and her parents did not take it well at all.

then I said. “While I love my siblings they’re not my kids. They’re your kids.” Am I the A**hole for saying that to them? They say I’m not being empathetic but I feel like they’re just saying this to me so that my siblings don’t come to them, asking them for help instead. I’m willing to hear all perspectives on this.

So, Was She Wrong to Say It?

Her parents clearly value a close family where everyone looks out for each other, and that is not a bad thing. But expecting a 19-year-old to anticipate her teenage siblings’ every need sounds more like a parenting job than a sibling one. Redditors widely agreed she was not in the wrong, with many saying she was more parentified than she realised. Was her comment too harsh, or exactly what needed saying? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Peesyeasy on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *