WIBTA if I told my wife the truth about her singing voice?

His wife sang him a Broadway tune and asked if she has a good voice. He fibbed, she noticed. Should he tell her the truth about her singing?

1 min 0
WIBTA if I told my wife the truth about her singing voice?

Every long marriage runs on a few small kindnesses, and sometimes that includes a well-meant fib. One husband thought he had handled an innocent question about his wife’s singing perfectly. Then came an impromptu performance, an expectant look and a reaction he could not quite sell. Now he wonders whether honesty might be the better gift, or a very big mistake.

WIBTA if I told my wife the truth about her singing voice? - Last night something sort of odd happened between me (M, 39) and my wife of almost a decade (F, 37). She asked me if I thought she had a good singing voice and I said, "Sure, you have a nice singing voice." “You never tell me that,” she countered. I kind of shrugged and reassured her as best I could that she indeed has a good voice. Then she proceeded to sing a Broadway tune (think along the lines of Annie’s “Tomorrow.”) Now, she’s not a terrible singer but she is not that talented either, realistically. She didn’t even know all the words to the
song, but she drew out many of the syllables and repeated the parts she did know over and over, so it felt like I was sitting there listening to her sing for an extended period of time, and it quickly became uncomfortable. She has a kind of old-timey timbre to her voice, which is somehow off putting. At the end she looked at me expectantly and I told her how great she was at singing. Unfortunately, I’m not that amazing of a liar, and I think she was a little unconvinced. So, WIBTA if I told her the truth about her mediocre singing voice? Do I wait to see if she asks me again? Seems like a harmless thing to lie about, but I’m also a little concerned she may start putting these solo

The private concert had already stretched on longer than he expected, and his polite smile was wearing thin. When the song finally ended, his wife turned to him for a verdict, and a hint in what she said next made him worry this was only the beginning.

concerts on for me more frequently because she said something like, “why don’t we sing more together?” I can keep up the ruse if that’s the best thing to do, but I’m curious what you all think.

So, Should He Tell Her the Truth?

Honesty matters in a marriage, and some would argue a spouse deserves a real answer when she asks. Still, singing for fun at home hurts nobody, and an unprompted critique could crush a joy she clearly treasures. Most Redditors felt he would be in the wrong to bring it up, calling this exactly what gentle white lies are for, though some suggested finding kind, specific compliments instead. Where do you stand? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Independent_Dot_8929 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *