AITAH for not cooking non-vegetarian food for Christmas?

His girlfriend wants him to cook brisket and meat dishes for Christmas, but he has been vegetarian for ten years and has never cooked meat in his life.

1 min 0
AITAH for not cooking non-vegetarian food for Christmas?

He is the cook in the house, and he has been vegetarian for a decade. So when his girlfriend asked him to make brisket and a spread of meat dishes for their first Christmas hosting her sister, he hesitated. She says it is about love and family memories. He says it is about something much harder to explain.

AITAH for not cooking non-vegetarian food for Christmas? - I have been vegetarian (Vegetarian not Vegan and by choice, no dietary restrictions) for the last decade since I was a teenager. Don’t eat meat, fish or even eggs. I don’t impose my lifestyle on others around me, have no problem with people eating non vegetarian near me. My GF moved in with me a few months back. I do the cooking and dishes everyday. Obviously I cook vegetarian food but I make sure I take care of the macros, enough protein and all, and I think I am decent enough cook.
My GF eats what I cook most days, and if she doesn’t feel like it she gets take outs or delivery. Thing is we’ll be hosting my GF’s sister and a couple of my girlfriend’s school friends over Christmas. My GF wants me to cook a brisket and a bunch of other non vegetarian dishes. I have never cooked meat in my life, don’t know how to. I told her she’s happy to cook up anything she wants. She says she’s terrible at it (She is and that’s why it’s me cooking every time lol). I told her we can order Delivery or go out to eat? But she wants to do a home Christmas this year as this is both her and her sister’s third Christmas without their parents

Their kitchen routine worked well most of the year. But the upcoming holiday brought a request that challenged everything about the way he cooks, and his girlfriend had a very personal reason for asking.

and family. (Parents no longer exist). First time she’ll be celebrating with her sister since then and that she misses the way she had Christmas back home. And that if I love her enough I can learn a few dishes and cook on the day. But… Animals kinda freak me out, even dead ones, one of the primary reasons I gave up meat. Something about the smell and the blood and the way muscle fibres look when cutting up meat. I think it’s a lot of effort for something I can’t even taste myself.

Her reasons were emotional and hard to argue with. Still, he had his own reasons for saying no, and some of them ran deeper than just not knowing his way around a roast.

I genuinely don’t have time to learn, and don’t want my first experiment at cooking meat to be on the actual day incase I royally f**k-up. I am swamped at work (work 6 days week) and was kind of planning to dedicate my free time on Sundays to GTA 6 Can’t do it on weekdays cause the chicken dish she wants and the brisket will take hours to make, not possible to learn and cook on days I’m working Now she’s being kinda passive aggressive with me, saying things like if I love her enough I’ll do this for her and stuff. And I am feeling really s**tty and kinda an a**hole. So my Reddit friends AITAH?

So, Is He the Problem Here?

Wanting a home-cooked Christmas that feels like the ones she lost is deeply human, and some might say a little effort is a fair gift. But asking a squeamish vegetarian to master brisket on the big day is a lot, especially when takeout and other options are on the table. Redditors largely backed him, with many calling the if-you-loved-me line unfair. Should he learn or hold firm? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/boovieworm on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *