He is the cook in the house, and he has been vegetarian for a decade. So when his girlfriend asked him to make brisket and a spread of meat dishes for their first Christmas hosting her sister, he hesitated. She says it is about love and family memories. He says it is about something much harder to explain.
Their kitchen routine worked well most of the year. But the upcoming holiday brought a request that challenged everything about the way he cooks, and his girlfriend had a very personal reason for asking.
Her reasons were emotional and hard to argue with. Still, he had his own reasons for saying no, and some of them ran deeper than just not knowing his way around a roast.
So, Is He the Problem Here?
Wanting a home-cooked Christmas that feels like the ones she lost is deeply human, and some might say a little effort is a fair gift. But asking a squeamish vegetarian to master brisket on the big day is a lot, especially when takeout and other options are on the table. Redditors largely backed him, with many calling the if-you-loved-me line unfair. Should he learn or hold firm? Share your verdict in the comments.
Source: This story was originally shared by u/boovieworm on r/AITAH.


