AITA for calling my MIL out in front of the family?

A mom keeps catching her mother-in-law breaking her parenting rules, so she starts calling her out in front of everyone. Now MIL wants it done in private.

2 min 1 0
AITA for calling my MIL out in front of the family?

Every parent has rules, and every family seems to have one relative who treats those rules like suggestions. For this mom, that relative is her mother-in-law: a grandmother who bribes the kids for hugs and sneaks sugar to a baby behind her back. After one too many incidents, the mom stopped speaking quietly. Now Grandma says she’s been humiliated.

AITA for calling my MIL out in front of the family? - The other day my mother-in-law came over with my father-in-law. They wanted to see us but mostly my kids. My oldest has the habit of giving my FIL a hug when he asks but says no to my MIL when she asks. Multiple times she has then bribed my oldest with a gift she brought, saying " I guess I won't give this to you if you don't give me a hug...". In the moment I say "you don't need to hug anyone you don't want to", loudly enough that both can hear it. Both times, this happened in front of my spouse, my FIL, and spouses siblings/spouses. Back story:

What looks like a small moment over a hug is really the latest chapter in a much longer pattern. To understand why this mom reacts so firmly, readers need to know what Grandma has already tried with the youngest child’s diet.

I've also scolded her for giving my youngest icing from a cake before they were one year old. We have been pretty strict about listening to our pediatrician about keeping the amount of sugary foods as low as possible before our kids turn 2. They've gotten peanut butter and some other foods with sugar but nothing overly gratuitous. She has tried to give both kids desserts and super sugary drinks (think purple drink), numerous times. Each time we have told her no and explained we aren't going to do it before they turn 2. Each time she acts like we are crazy and tries to convince us that it isn't a big deal? While also acting dumb, like its the first time she's heard this
information. Over the summer we were at a larger, extended family gathering and i saw my 1 YO had a blue mouth, the same blue as the icing that was on the cake. I asked if she had given her icing and she said she had and she didn't tell me because she knew I would say no. I was furious and told her loudly that she was disrespectful for this, since she knew better but did it anyway. She tried to play it off "cutely" but I was p**sed and stormed out. She left shortly after Today(a few days after the latest hug scenario)I got a call from her, where she was sad, saying that I humiliated her and that while she respects my parenting rules, she would really

By this point, the rules had been explained again and again, and Grandma kept acting surprised every time. Then came a summer family gathering and one very telling detail: a little one’s mouth stained the exact shade of blue as the cake icing.

appreciate if I would pull her aside to tell her not to do things instead of announcing it out loud. Am I the a**hole for not pulling her aside to say this and instead calling her out? Would I be the a**hole for continuing to call her out?

So, Was She Wrong to Say It Out Loud?

Grandma’s request sounds reasonable on paper: a quiet word instead of a public scolding. But the mom had already tried quiet words, many times, and the rules were broken anyway. Reddit sided with her almost unanimously, arguing that someone who truly respected the rules would simply follow them, and a few asked where her spouse stands in all this. What do you think? Should she keep calling Grandma out, or switch to private chats? Tell us in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/muchgreaterthanG_O_D on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *