AITA for calling out my mom for saying nasty things about my brother because he hates my son

Her teenage stepbrother wants nothing to do with her baby. When their mom vented that she doesn't even like him, within his earshot, she stepped in.

2 min 1 0
AITA for calling out my mom for saying nasty things about my brother because he hates my son

Blended families come with complicated feelings, and this one has plenty. A young mom’s teenage stepbrother has ignored her son since before he was born, and she has made peace with it. Their mother has not. When Mom’s frustration boiled over into something cruel said within earshot of the boy, the young mom decided she couldn’t stay quiet any longer.

AITA for calling out my mom for saying nasty things about my brother because he hates my son - My (30f) brother (14m), let’s call him “Eric” has borderline hated my son since before he was born. Back story, I’ve known my brother since he was 9m old and he was an extremely behavioral child (like more than developmentally normal). His mother refused to seek out help until he was around 7. Eventually, he was put on a medication that has worked wonders so he’s much better with regulation and listening when he’s told to do a task. We were close-ish for a while but after I got pregnant, he stopped
talking to me and didn’t care about ANYTHING if it involved the baby. He even went so far as to say “lol no” when I asked “if I were to trip and fall, would you try to catch the baby”. (Which in hindsight, I know it was wrong to set him up like that) Fast forward a year after my son, “Jack” was born and he completely ignores him all the time. Refuses to look at him, engage in conversation if Jack is brought up, and blatantly ignores him if he comes up to play with him. It bothered me for a while but it doesn’t really anymore. I’ve come to the conclusion that he doesn’t like babies or little kids because they overstimulate him (suspected ND). However, this

So the distance between Eric and the baby started early and only grew. Over the next year it became a household sore spot, and while his sister learned to let it go, their mother kept pushing for the bond she wanted to see.

bothers my mother “Dana” (51f) to no end. She constantly tries to get Eric to interact with Jack to no avail. One night that I thought was uncalled for was when she tried to get him to say goodnight and he looked away from him and grumbled “goodnight”. My mom yelled at him “JUST LOOK AT HIM D**N IT” and Eric just walked up the stairs expressionless. This is not what got to me. What got to me was as he was going upstairs, my mom was ranting about how “he hates babies. He just hates babies. I don’t care if he hates him, he should still interact with him. You don’t see me ignoring Eric because I don’t like him. I don’t

One goodnight that went wrong could have been the end of it. But what came next, said while Eric was still on the stairs, is what changed the mood of the whole evening and pushed his sister to speak up.

like him but I can be civil with him.” There is not a doubt in my mind that Eric heard this. And the worst part was my mom was saying this to his father (48m) and he did absolutely nothing to defend his son. I stepped in and said that “I can’t make Eric like babies, even mine. Yeah, it sucks that he doesn’t have a relationship with his nephew, but that’s his choice. Jack has even started ignoring him so he’s not bothered and I’m not bothered so don’t get bothered for me. I think it’s more offensive that you are talking about a 14 yo boy in the way you are.”

She had said her piece in defense of a 14-year-old who had probably heard every word. Her mother, though, saw things very differently, and her answer revealed how much hurt was sitting underneath it all.

My mom got upset with this and went on about how she was the only real mother figure in his life (his mother “Trish” was inconsistent with her parenting style and it did affect him in the long term, my mother was always warm with Eric up to this point) and it hurts that he ignores her too. So I’m wondering am I the a**hole for saying what I did? ETA: to clear any confusion, he is my stepbrother but I call him my brother because I’ve known him most of his life Another ETA: if it adds anything, Eric is the youngest of 6 in a VERY blended family and the only boy. Oldest sister is 32, I’m 30, stepsister is 22, and my twin
half sisters are 19, so he’s the baby AND the only boy. ANOTHER ETA: y’all please don’t attack his father, I failed to add that he has a rare autoimmune disease that is neurodegenerative so he IS cognitively impaired

Did She Do the Right Thing?

Nobody comes out of this evening looking perfect, but most readers felt the daughter got it right. On Reddit, the overwhelming verdict was NTA: you can teach a teenager good manners, many pointed out, but you can’t order him to feel affection. Many readers also expressed real sympathy for Eric, a boy who seems to need someone in his corner. Was she right to speak up, or should she have stayed out of it? Share your thoughts below.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/astros**t3000 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *