AITA for naming my baby after my mother-in-law?

A new mum named her daughter after her supportive mother-in-law, but her sister-in-law says the name was stolen and is demanding a legal change.

2 min 1 0
AITA for naming my baby after my mother-in-law?

Naming a baby after a beloved family member is usually seen as one of the sweetest tributes possible. So when a new mother, living far from her own family, quietly chose to honour the mother-in-law who supported her through every step of her pregnancy, she expected happy tears. She did get them, at first. Then her sister-in-law came to visit.

AITA for naming my baby after my mother-in-law? - This situation is making me crazy. At this point, I am happy with any advice someone might have. I (34F) got married some years ago, his family was very welcoming to me, they treat me so well, it's great! I got pregnant in the beginning of the year, again, his family was very supportive of me. My MIL was there for each step, for context, I am an immigrant, so my whole my family lives in another country, 12 hours away, not so easy to come and go, so my MIL was very present at my pregnancy.

With her own parents an ocean away, her mother-in-law became her anchor during pregnancy. Wanting to say thank you in the most meaningful way she could imagine, she kept a special secret right up until the birth, never imagining it could cause any hurt.

We kept our baby name in secret, as a surprise, for my MIL. I decided to name my daughter after her, let's say that her name is Beatrice, I decided to name my dauther Marie Beatrice. She's been great to me since ever, I just felt like it was a nice hommage to her. When the baby was born, she loved, she was very happy, everyone was happy, no problem, then my sister-in-law (31F) came to visit us. She said she didn't want to talk about it at the hospital, but she felt that it was very insincery and manipulative of me to name my daughter after her mother. That her mother already treated me like a daughter, and that now I was stealing this from her,
because she decided to name her daughter after MIL since she was 12. That surprised me, it was first week, I was very stressed, I felt that I could've been misunderstanding, I talked that with my husband, and he said that his sister wasn't even sure about being a mother. I wasn't misunderstanding, she came around again another day, her brother was here, she accused him of doing to spite her, that he knew that she wanted to name her daughter after her mother and we were taking that from her. They had a huge fight, my husband said that she could still name her after her mother, that names aren't exclusives, I had to ask her to

Barely a week after giving birth and running on no sleep, she wondered whether she had simply misunderstood. But her sister-in-law was not finished, and her next visit, with her brother in the room, turned a quiet complaint into a full-blown family explosion.

leave because they were screaming. My husband swears that he had no idea of this desire of her, and to be honest, in the 6 years, I never heard her talking about being a mother. I tried to talk with her, explain to her my reasons, that it was a decision made to show her mother how grateful I am. No talk. She said that I could still change the my daughter's name legally, and that I should do that if I want my daughter to have her in her life. I didn't want to bring my in-laws in this matter, but my husband did anyway, they told us to not worry about it, that SIL does that from time to time, however the situation is awful, because she doesn't answer me anymore, we

Even the grandparents seemed unsurprised by the outburst, but that did little to calm things down. With a big family Christmas approaching and both sets of grandparents travelling to meet the baby, the new mum tried one more time to make peace.

are planning a big Christmas this year, her parents will come, my parents will come, it'll be their first time meeting their granddaughter, my brother is coming, it's supposed to be a celebration, and she said to me MIL to not count on her to be here. That we died for her. I really don't know what to do anymore. Am I being unreasonable? Am I the a**hole in this situation?

So, Was She Wrong to Honour Her Mother-in-Law?

It is possible the sister-in-law truly had a long-held dream, and losing it can sting. But nobody owns a name, and demanding that a newborn’s name be legally changed is a huge leap. Redditors were almost unanimous in backing the new mother, describing the sister-in-law’s reaction as jealous and out of proportion, especially since her husband says the name can still be shared. What would you do in her place? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Mean_Fail1856 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *