AITA for telling my in-laws their kids couldn’t stay overnight during the holidays

A couple hosting the holiday meal said no overnight guests this year, and the in-laws are now insisting the decision is pushing the whole family away.

1 min 2 0
AITA for telling my in-laws their kids couldn’t stay overnight during the holidays

Hosting a holiday meal is a lot of work, and hosting the whole family overnight is a whole different level. When one couple with odd work shifts and a tiny home decided this year’s gathering would be dinner only, they thought a polite group message and a list of nearby hotels would settle it. The family, it turned out, had other ideas.

AITA for telling my in-laws their kids couldn’t stay overnight during the holidays - My partner and I finally decided a few weeks ago that we would host a family holiday meal but not an overnight stay. We both work odd shifts and our place is small, so the couch situation was already tight before the guests even arrived. I sent a polite message to the family group chat laying out the new rule and suggesting local hotels for anyone who wanted to stay the night. My partner's parents wrote back that it was a bad idea because their two youngest kids would have to drive after dark, and they reminded us that everyone had always slept over
in past years. I explained that the schedule hadn't changed and the house just didn't have the room this time. They ended up booking a hotel but have been texting me individually since the meal, saying it felt like we were pushing the family away. I still think the limit made sense, but I'm starting to wonder if I should have just dealt with the discomfort for one night instead.

So, Were They Wrong to Skip the Sleepover?

Tradition carries a lot of weight, and it is easy to see why the in-laws felt a little shut out after years of sleepovers. But a small home and demanding schedules are real limits, and the couple gave plenty of notice along with alternatives. Most Redditors sided firmly with the poster, with several suggesting an earlier mealtime so nobody has to drive after dark. Was the no-overnight rule reasonable? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Merrynata540 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *