AITA for refusing to allow my brother to rent my late parents house

After losing both parents, his brother wanted to keep the family home and pay out his share over 20 years. He wanted his inheritance much sooner.

2 min 0
AITA for refusing to allow my brother to rent my late parents house

Losing both parents within a short time is devastating enough. For one 35-year-old father, the grief came with a difficult inheritance question: what should happen to the family home his brother still lives in? His siblings have a heartfelt plan to keep it in the family. He has a mortgage, a young daughter, and a very different idea.

AITA for refusing to allow my brother to rent my late parents house - Both my parents passed away in a short timeframe of each other. In the will they left everything to me (M35) and my two siblings. Sister (F39) and Brother (M43). I live with my wife and daughter in a house with 15 years of mortgage still to pay off. My sister has brought her house outright with partner and kids. My brother returned to my parents house around 15 years ago after living away and lived with them with his partner. My parents didn’t have many financial savings but did leave the house they lived in (where
my brother still lives) to us. My brother has suggested we keep the house as it’s our family house and the one we all grew up in and our grandparents did too which i understand and as a compromise wants to pay rent to Me and My Sister until he has paid us out of our share. That’s going to take over 20 years due to the value of the house and what he is prepared to pay us. My sister is happy with that, she’s already paid off her house and for her she sees it as a monthly payment she wouldn’t otherwise get, she also has much more of an emotional tie to the house than I do as she’s quite a sentimental person and live there a long time but i’m not sentimental, moved out as soon

The brother’s proposal sounds warm and sentimental on paper, keeping generations of memories under one roof. But once the numbers are worked out, the timeline involved turns this into a much bigger ask than it first appears.

as I could and don’t really have any emotional regard for the house. To clarify - i was still well involved in my parents life and we had a loving relationship, i didn’t see them as much as he lived at the house as mentioned and my sister brought a house around the corner where as i live nearly an hour away for us while those payments would help it means we’re still paying off our mortgage and all the interest with it! I want to be able to pay it off and have suggested either selling the house and splitting profit three ways or advising my brother to get a loan for the value of 1/3 of the house, pay that to me so he would own 2/3 and then do a

Feeling outnumbered by his more sentimental siblings, he was not simply saying no. He came to the table with alternatives of his own, and they show just how much he was willing to bend to make things fair.

deal with my sister. I’ve also offered to adjust the amount and give him some extra money as he was more involved in my parents end of life care than i was (he lived at the house and doesn’t have a young child like i do, plus i’m nearly an hour away from home) so i have said we can work out an extra amount for him to componsate him for that even tho the is no requirement for that in my parents will. My sister and brother both feel i’m being selfish and not considering the family history but the money would provide a financial freedom to my family and my daughter that a monthly payment wouldn’t!
so AITA?

So, Is He Being Selfish?

It is natural for his brother and sister to want to hold on to the home where their family history lives, and caring for the parents at the end deserves recognition. But asking one sibling to wait over twenty years for his share, with no interest, while he pays his own mortgage is a lot. Redditors broadly backed him, calling the loan or sale options fair and generous. Would you hold out for your share or keep the house in the family? Share your verdict in the comments!

Source: This story was originally shared by u/ProfessionalImage701 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *