AITAH for calling my friend ‘overconsumption -core’ over what she told me

While she packed her bedsheets for a move, her friend scoffed and said to just buy new ones. Her blunt reply about overconsumption left a chill.

2 min 0
AITAH for calling my friend ‘overconsumption -core’ over what she told me

Moving day is stressful enough without someone questioning how you pack. One 23-year-old student was carefully folding her bedsheets and vacuum sealing her pillow when a visiting friend stared at her in disbelief. Why bother, she asked, when you can simply buy new ones? A small comment quickly snowballed into a clash over money, waste and one very pointed comeback.

AITAH for calling my friend ‘overconsumption -core’ over what she told me - I (23F) have been packing up to move pretty far from where I am and my friend (22F) dropped by to spend sometime with me while I packed.She saw me folding up my bedsheets and vacuum sealing my pillow and gave me a weird look and asked why I was packing them up in genuine disbelief. I thought I was packing it up wrong or something so I asked her what she meant and she basically said ‘why are you packing them up? Just buy some new ones when you get there. That’s what I always do’

Her friend’s casual suggestion might have passed without a second thought. But the conversation was only getting started, and the more the young woman learned about her friend’s moving habits, the harder it became to bite her tongue.

We are students so we move quite often, and both of us have moved approximately 3 times in the last 4 years and I asked her if she does it each time. She said yes and urged me to toss my she again. The tone she used the entire time kinda rubbed me the wrong way, cause it sounded weirdly condescending, like I was being stupid, and I responded by saying ‘well that’s a bit too over-consumption core for me, since the sheets aren’t even a year old’ Also they’re really cute and are still soft af Friend rolled her eyes at me and got annoyed at me for being an ‘eco-warrior’ which pmo because

Being labeled an eco-warrior stung, and the student was not ready to let it go. With the packing tape still in her hand, she fired back one more line, and it is the moment she now wonders whether she should apologize for.

sorry for caring about the environment? But I don’t think this even counts as being an eco-warrior or whatever. I just don’t want to toss perfectly good sheets I responded with something also the lines of ‘well maybe, but it’s better than whatever you’re doing by ordering everything of she*n’ and went back to packing. She didn’t leave after that since we were meeting some other friends later but the vibe felt off. Should I apologise, I feel like that last line might’ve been harsh?

So, Should She Apologize?

Nobody enjoys being judged for their spending, and her friend may have felt the final jab about online shopping was personal. Still, the friend opened with a condescending tone and mocked her for keeping perfectly good sheets. Redditors overwhelmingly said she was not in the wrong, with many praising her for refusing to waste things that still work. Was that last comeback fair, or a little too sharp? Share your verdict in the comments!

Source: This story was originally shared by u/pleasehelpbeel on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *