Some keepsakes carry more than their price tag. When a young woman’s father asked if he could give her late mother’s engagement ring to his partner, she found herself caught between keeping the peace at home and protecting one of the last pieces of her mum. Her answer, she fears, may change things between them for good.
His request came with plenty of reasons, from the ring’s value to the couple’s age. But she noticed something about the order in which things had happened, and it made the conversation feel far less like a question.
She offered him another option, one that seemed like a fair solution. Yet he simply asked her to keep thinking it over, and the weight of that request has stayed with her ever since.
So, Would She Be Wrong to Say No?
Her father may simply want to show his partner how much she means to him, and asking at all was a respectful step. But this ring belonged to her mother, and it was discussed and even tried on before she was asked. Redditors were strongly on her side, saying the ring should stay with her and questioning why another ring was not good enough. What would you do in her place? Share your verdict in the comments.
Source: This story was originally shared by u/6FingeredWoman on r/AmItheA**hole.


