WIBTA if I said no to my dad giving my stepmom a ring?

Her dad asked if he could give her late mother's engagement ring to his partner, after the partner had already tried it on. Would she be wrong to refuse?

2 min 0
WIBTA if I said no to my dad giving my stepmom a ring?

Some keepsakes carry more than their price tag. When a young woman’s father asked if he could give her late mother’s engagement ring to his partner, she found herself caught between keeping the peace at home and protecting one of the last pieces of her mum. Her answer, she fears, may change things between them for good.

WIBTA if I said no to my dad giving my stepmom a ring? - The ring in question is my dead mother's engagement ring. I (28f) have an ok but somewhat contentious relationship with my father and step mother (late 60s/early 70s). They are common law, as she has been living with us for 8 years. He got her a Pandora band several years ago for Christmas, we all teared up together and I found it very sweet. He recently approached me asking if he could give her my mother's engagement ring saying "it's a $10,000 ring that's just sitting there". He discussed it with her first, then told her he
would have to get my approval. She has already tried it on, he let me know she wouldn't be wearing it on her wedding finger. He even sited their age, saying I'd be getting it in 15-20 years when they die anyways. We are not good at having difficult conversations, but I was able to express that I wouldn't be comfortable with it. He had given me his first wife's engagement ring when I was younger, I never wear it and offered it to him to give to her instead. (It was actually the same ring he had originally proposed to my mother with but she asked for one of her own.) He just told me to think about it, regarding my mom's ring.

His request came with plenty of reasons, from the ring’s value to the couple’s age. But she noticed something about the order in which things had happened, and it made the conversation feel far less like a question.

I wear my mother's wedding band everyday on my right middle finger. I don't think too often about the engagement ring, but I guess I thought it would be gifted to me sometime or my partner may ask for it in the future for my own hypothetical engagement. I think I will stand by my decision but odds are there will be some resentment and honestly he might give it to her anyways. I feel strange about it but don't want to deny her a ring. I think it was kind of him to ask me at all, but the fact he had already discussed it with her and my saying no makes me feel like an a**hole already.

She offered him another option, one that seemed like a fair solution. Yet he simply asked her to keep thinking it over, and the weight of that request has stayed with her ever since.

tldr; My dad asked me if he could give my stepmom my dead mom's engagement ring after talking with my stepmom about it first and letting her try it on.

So, Would She Be Wrong to Say No?

Her father may simply want to show his partner how much she means to him, and asking at all was a respectful step. But this ring belonged to her mother, and it was discussed and even tried on before she was asked. Redditors were strongly on her side, saying the ring should stay with her and questioning why another ring was not good enough. What would you do in her place? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/6FingeredWoman on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *