AITA for not letting my flatmate have my favorite perfume that she broke?

Her flatmate broke her favourite perfume and promised to replace it, then asked to keep what was left in the cracked bottle. She said no. Was that fair?

1 min 0
AITA for not letting my flatmate have my favorite perfume that she broke?

Lending your favourite perfume to a flatmate for a family event feels like a kind gesture. But when the bottle slipped and cracked, a simple accident turned into an awkward argument about who actually gets to keep what was left inside it. Both of them think they are being perfectly reasonable, and neither is backing down.

AITA for not letting my flatmate have my favorite perfume that she broke? - We are both in our 20s, we are friendly but not close. A few days ago she asked to use my good perfume because she was going to a family event, I said sure, but she dropped accidentally when she was putting it down and it broke and spilled. it didn’t fully shatter though and then she tilted it and tissues around it so about half stayed in the bottle. She did say she was sorry and that she would replace it, but then she asked if she could have what was left in the cracked one, so she could put it into another bottle and use it.

The flatmate apologised and promised to buy a replacement, which seemed fair. But her follow-up request caught the perfume’s owner off guard, and her answer to it is what has left the two of them at odds.

I’m not upset that she asked but it’s still my perfume, just because she broke it and has to replace it doesn’t entitle her to the perfume bottle that was mine from the start. So I said there’s still enough left and it was expensive enough that I was going to put it into another bottle for myself, so no. Then she got upset and she’s buying me a whole new one so there’s no real problem for me, I should at least let her have something from the money she has to spend, and she didn’t break it on purpose. Which is true, but she’s paying to fix her mistake, I don’t think that means she “deserves” my perfume for herself. When she broke it she did ask if there was sentimental value to the perfume or if it was a gift and it wasn’t, but that
doesn’t mean it’s not important to me, it’s a good perfume and my favorite special one.

So, Was She Being Unfair?

It was her perfume first, and it is natural to feel protective of a favourite scent. But her flatmate is paying for a full new bottle, so keeping the leftovers too means ending up with more than she started with. Redditors largely said she was in the wrong here, arguing that a replacement and the leftovers should not both go to her. Who do you think deserves the broken bottle? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/justaspark77 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *