AITAH for refusing to leave our dogs home alone on Christmas so my BIL can bring his new puppy?

Her in-laws asked them to leave their epileptic dog home alone on Christmas for a new puppy, and her partner's suggestion made things even worse.

1 min 0
AITAH for refusing to leave our dogs home alone on Christmas so my BIL can bring his new puppy?

Christmas plans can unravel fast when pets enter the picture. One woman and her partner always bring their two dogs to the family celebration, including an older pup with epilepsy. This year, her mother-in-law asked them to leave the dogs at home to make room for someone else’s new puppy, and the suggestion that followed hurt even more.

AITAH for refusing to leave our dogs home alone on Christmas so my BIL can bring his new puppy? - My partner and I have two dogs. One is older and has epilepsy, so we're generally careful about leaving him alone for extended periods. Today, my MIL called my partner to discuss Christmas plans. The plan is drinks around 3–4 PM, followed by dinner around 6:30 PM. We usually don't leave until around 9 PM. She asked us to leave our dogs at home this year because my BIL and his partner recently got a French Bulldog puppy who won't be fully vaccinated by Christmas.
They're planning to bring him to dinner. Our dogs are fully vaccinated. My partner explained that we aren't comfortable leaving them home alone for 6–7 hours, especially given our older dog's epilepsy. Finding a dog sitter on Christmas Day would also be difficult and very expensive. We live approximately 1.5 hours away, so driving three hours round-trip just to attend for a short time isn't practical either. My MIL's response was essentially that it's okay if we don't come and we come another day instead. What really surprised me was the apparent lack of interest in finding a compromise. Why couldn't the

Leaving the dogs alone for most of the day was off the table, and a sitter on Christmas would cost a fortune. That left the couple searching for another option, but the family’s response was not what she expected.

dogs be kept separate? Why is the solution automatically that our dogs stay home? Now my partner has suggested that he simply goes to Christmas dinner while I stay home with the dogs. I don't have family here (they live overseas), so Christmas with his family is also my opportunity to spend the holidays with family. The other couple is celebrating Christmas Eve with her family, so I'm struggling to understand why we're expected to make all the sacrifices here. I understand wanting to protect a young, incompletely vaccinated puppy. But AITA for refusing to leave our dogs alone for that long and expecting my partner to
spend Christmas with me and the dogs rather than going without me?

So, Was She Being Unreasonable?

Protecting a young, unvaccinated puppy is a fair concern, and some might say a host can set the rules for her own home. But no one tried to find a middle ground, and her partner seemed ready to celebrate without her. Redditors mostly sided with her, saving their sharpest criticism for the partner who offered to leave her behind on Christmas. Where do you stand? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Healthy_Cry_3121 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *