AITA for yelling and kicking my friend out of my party?

She told her friend over and over not to bring her boyfriend. When he crashed her girls-only Friendsgiving anyway, the host finally lost her temper.

2 min 0
AITA for yelling and kicking my friend out of my party?

Four best friends, four years of easy friendship, and then one new boyfriend who seemed to show up everywhere he was not invited. When the host of a girls-only Friendsgiving saw him walk through her door anyway, years of polite requests finally boiled over in front of every single guest at her party.

AITA for yelling and kicking my friend out of my party? - I (23F) am part of a close friend group of four girls. We’ve been friends four years and haven’d had an issue till him Alvin met Brittney at a church event, and she was IMMEDIATELY smitten. The rest of us were skeptical, to put it nicely. He’s about 12 years older than us, has a four-year-old son he never sees, and the kid was a result of him cheating on his ex while she was in the hospital. Bang-up guy. We brought up our concerns, but Brittney insisted he had turned his life around.
We decided to give him the benefit of the doubt, but he continued to disappoint. He has no filter, makes inappropriate jokes, and often says rude things to our friends. We repeatedly tried talking to her about the red flags, but she always doubled down. Eventually, we decided to let it go. Since graduating, she’s been bringing him to EVERY event. Every hangout, party, dinner… he’s there. We’ve asked her not to bring him, and she’ll agree, but something always conveniently comes up. For example, three weeks ago, Jeanette’s family invited us to dinner to celebrate her grad school acceptance. They specifically said no plus ones

The group tried to make peace with the situation, but the boyfriend did not stay in the background for long. Soon he was turning up to events where he had never been invited, and the friends began to notice a pattern.

because they only had a reservation for 10. Eleanor and I showed up without our boyfriends. Who walks in? Brittney and Alvin. They ignored us pointing out there were 11 people at a 10-person table, and he started watching YouTube on his phone. It was incredibly awkward. Afterward, Jeanette, Eleanor, and I agreed to stand our ground next time. Cut to the story at hand. Every year, we have a Friendsgiving with our larger friend group from our women’s org (emphasis on “women”). It’s a potluck with some light bonding activities. Since I was hosting, I sent out the RSVP. The invitation VERY CLEARLY said no plus ones. I even sent reminders in the group
chat and everyone liked the message. The party rolls around yesterday, and guess who shows up? Not only was Alvin there, he was visibly under the influence. I immediately stomped over and told him to leave. Brittney was shocked and claimed she thought the rule didn’t apply to her since we were so close. Came to a head when Alvin said, “OP, it’s not that deep. Stop being a b** about it.” I kind of blacked out after that line, but apparently I started yelling before Jeanette jumped in to assist. Somewhere in this I called him a “grown-a man who doesn’t need babysitting.” We went back and forth, and

With the rules made crystal clear and every guest confirming they understood, the host expected a relaxed evening with the women from her group. Then the party got going, and the one person who was not supposed to be there walked straight in.

Brittney refused to budge. Eventually, I told her to leave as well. She dragged him out before either could say anything more. The party resumed, but a few friends said I was kind of harsh. They agreed with kicking him out but thought the argument was too much. I’m pretty sure I’m justified in wanting him to leave since it was a girls-only party, but maybe my approach was off. I’ve respectfully asked her not to bring him multiple times, and this was my breaking point. Brittney is one of my closest friends, and I consider her a sister. I don’t want this to become a bigger deal than it is.

The guests went back to their food and games, but the mood had shifted. Some friends quietly told the host she went too far, and now she is wondering whether she was right to hold her ground in such a loud way.

So, Reddit, AITA?

So, Was She Wrong to Throw Them Out?

Yelling at a party is never anyone’s idea of a good time, and her friends had a point that things got heated. But she had asked politely, again and again, and the invitation could not have been clearer. Redditors firmly sided with the host, with many saying they were more worried about her friend than about the shouting. Was this a fair breaking point, or should she have kept it quieter? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/ehull-543 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *