AITA for forcing a crying friend to leave my home?

She was exhausted and overstimulated when a sobbing friend showed up unannounced. After an hour of trying to help, she asked her to leave. Was that cruel?

2 min 0
AITA for forcing a crying friend to leave my home?

After a draining week at work, all she wanted was a quiet dinner and an early night with her two cats. Then the doorbell rang, and a friend in full panic was standing on her doorstep. What followed was an hour that tested her patience, her limits and, now, a friendship she never meant to hurt.

AITA for forcing a crying friend to leave my home? - To, to preface, I (31F) have adhd and autism and work overstimulates me a lot in general. So when I see people or do things outside of the house, I mostly plan them in advance so I can make sure that the day before that is calm or that I at least can mentally prepare. So, I live alone with my two cats. A few weeks ago, I had a pretty stressful week at work and thus, I came home tired and overstimulated. The kind that even the hair annoys you against your head. I was making dinner and after that was planning to go to bed when the doorbell rings.

She opened the door anyway, hoping she could find the calm she usually brings to moments like this. But the visitor was far more worked up than she expected, and every attempt to help seemed to make things louder instead of softer.

A friend is on my doorstep crying and panicking about something work related. I immediately was at a loss. Normally I am quite good at soothing people, but this time I just didn't have the mindspace for it. Nevertheless, I let her in the house and expanded dinner to include her, but she kept panicking and shouting and every perspective I tried to offer induced a new panic attack or a snarky response. And I just couldn't defuse it. I couldn't navigate the situations like I normally can and at some points I even got angry back. So after an hour I apologized to her, said I was too overstimulated to help her and asked her to leave. And since

The friend left upset, and the silence since then has been heavy. But there is one more detail she added later, and it changes how the whole evening looks: this was not the first unannounced crisis on her doorstep.

then she has been short and angry with me. I feel bad that I just wasn't able to shake myself awake from my mood and actually help her. But at the same time if she announced she wanted to come over, I would've said it wasn't a good time. So, AITA and should I apologize more? Edit; Just to give some context, this has happened before, about twice a month for a year. I was able to navigate it then and soothe her before, but this time I just wasn't able to get the situation to a good end. And I feel horrible about it.

So, Was She Wrong to Ask Her Friend to Leave?

It is hard to watch someone you care about fall apart, and her friend clearly needed support. But she let her in, fed her and tried for a full hour while running on empty herself. Redditors overwhelmingly said she was not the one in the wrong, pointing out that turning up unannounced twice a month is a lot to ask of anyone. Would you have handled it differently? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/CuriousCatnaps on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *