AITAH for bailing on a game my friend wants to make over AI?

A friend's tabletop game idea had them hooked, until he insisted on using AI for the art and playtesting. They quit just a minute after saying yes.

1 min 0
AITAH for bailing on a game my friend wants to make over AI?

A friend pitches a clever idea for a tabletop game, and suddenly one Redditor’s brain is buzzing with possibilities. When the invitation came to build it together, the answer was an instant yes. About a minute later, it became a no, all because of a single rule the two friends simply could not agree on.

AITAH for bailing on a game my friend wants to make over AI? - My friend had an idea for a Table Top game. I think it is a great idea. He brought up the core mechanic the other day and it spent my little ADHD brain spinning thinking of all the cool stuff you could do with it. Today he asked me if I would like to develop it with him and I said yes. Honestly I think it was a wonderful idea. There are games out there that are similar but none exactly like it, so we would both be making something brand new but also familiar enough that we have existing markets already out there to market to. And even if it flops, it will just be fun to do.

The excitement was real and the idea had promise. But this Redditor had one condition before signing on, and the friend’s answer turned a fun new project into a dealbreaker almost immediately.

I had one rule. No AI. He insists we will need AI. Not just for art but for play testing and proofing. He doesn't want to spend years playtesting. I feel AI doesn't give reliable play test output, is unnecessary, and is so toxic to a brand in table top game development that having it involved would k**l customer good will before the game even launches. I backed out of the project about a minute after I said yes to it over this issue. Me backing out means it probably wont ever get made. AITAH?

So, Was Walking Away Too Harsh?

The friend may simply want to work faster and keep costs down, and plenty of creators experiment with new tools. But setting a clear boundary at the start is fair, and the poster believes using AI would hurt the game with the very players it is meant for. Redditors strongly backed the poster, many arguing that AI is no substitute for real human playtesting. Would you have stuck with the project? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/The_Hermit_09 on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *