AITAH for not letting my brother/sister-in-laws dog around my kids?

A sister-in-law's German Shepherd has badly hurt other dogs, and now it's invited to Christmas Eve. One parent refuses to let it near the kids.

2 min 0
AITAH for not letting my brother/sister-in-laws dog around my kids?

Family gatherings can be stressful, but for one parent the worry goes far beyond awkward small talk. A large German Shepherd belonging to a sister-in-law has a history of serious attacks on other dogs. Now Christmas Eve is coming, the dog is invited, and this parent is the only one still refusing to let it near the kids.

AITAH for not letting my brother/sister-in-laws dog around my kids? - Here's the deal. My brother married a woman who had a German shepherd puppy at the time. Now she is 4-5ish and full grown. Since she has been a part of our family, that dog attacked other dogs many times. Here are the incidents that we know about. ⁠The owner (we'll call her SIL) went to the bathroom. The German shepherd Adolph (fake name) was sitting next to the door in what we realized later was a guarding position. My parents dog (yorkie/maltese mix) just happened to walk by. Adolph attacked my parents dog,
snatching her up by the head and thrashing. She would not let go. The only way we were able to get her to open her mouth was when the owner came out of the bathroom and eventually got her to let go. ALMOST k**led the little dog. Lots of blood. She had emergency surgery and lived another 2 years but was NEVER the same. Always jumpy and seemed in pain. The owners never took full responsibility and went out partying that same night. Left the dog locked in a room. No training or other measures were taken. ⁠I had my brother over to hang out and he brought the dog. I had 2 dogs at the time. We were sitting and watching TV and my ~45 lb mini bernadoodle walked

That first incident would have been enough to worry most people. But how the dog’s owners responded afterward told the family even more, and it was not long before something similar happened again, much closer to home.

near it and out of nowhere it attacked. Bit my dog around the neck and threw him. Again blood and a vet trip. Again my dog that was attacked had issues afterwards because of the bite. My brother apologized but the owner of the dog, my SIL never said a word. Still no training or anything. ⁠We stopped letting Adolph around any other dog or kids in the family and it really upset SIL. We went on vacation this year and while I went to get ice I overheard them talking in their balcony. I wasn't purposely eavesdropping but I very clearly heard them talking about Adolph. Apparently it has attacked many other times that our family wasn't aware of. One was her

Two serious attacks, two vet visits, and still no training. The family drew a firm line after that, but a trip away together later that year revealed something the poster had never been told about the dog’s past.

parents dog. Another few were their best friend's dog that they babysit sometimes. My brother was using those as examples of why Adolph was dangerous but she flipped out saying that none of those other attacks "broke the skin so they don't count as real attacks". So now I know I can't trust what they say about Adolph because they hid all of these other attacks from our side of the family. Flash forward, we often have family gatherings at my parents which is a big house. My brother and SIL with Adolph have no kids. I have 2 kids, 4 and 2 y/o and a 12 y/o golden doodle. And there's my sister with 3 kids, 2, 5, and 7 y/o. Initially following the attacks, everyone agreed

Knowing the dog’s full history changed everything for this parent. And with family gatherings at the grandparents’ home a regular thing, it was only a matter of time before that line in the sand was tested.

that the dog couldn't come. But as time has gone on, my parents started letting the dog come because my brother and SIL held them hostage, saying if the dog wasn't welcome then they wouldn't come. My sister had even come around now, saying her kids could be around the dog in small amounts. I have stood very firm with the opinion that under no circumstances could that dog be around my kids. Never. Not for a second. All it would take is 1 time and my child is scarred for life or even k**led. The dog is HUGE. At 4th of July, SIL threw a fit and made us out to be the bad guy for making them trap her "baby" in a room all weekend.

After a tense Fourth of July, the next big family event is fast approaching. It is a milestone birthday no one wants to miss, and the pressure to give in this time is building from every direction.

Now Christmas is coming and Xmas eve is my grandma's 90th birthday so we're all spending it at my parents. They insist on bringing the dog and I'm just so uncomfortable. I can't believe I'm the only one who sees this as a potential disaster and am feeling pressure to just let it go. I CANT! I feel letting my little kids around this dog would be gross negligence and it's ticking time b**b. Also let's not forget about MY dog who will likely be attacked if Adolph is around. AMIAH for sticking to my g**s here? Yes the dog has never attacked a child but it only takes once. If I were the dog parents there is NO WAY ON HELL I would ever let Adolph around any kids, let alone the ones I'm
supposed to love and care for.

So, Is This Parent Overreacting?

The dog’s owners clearly love their pet, and it has never hurt a child, so they feel unfairly judged. But a dog that has seriously injured other dogs, with incidents that were kept quiet, is a risk most parents would not take with toddlers. Redditors broadly sided with the poster, many saying the family should simply skip the gathering if the dog is there. Would you give in for one night? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/roscoeswetsuit8 on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *