WIBTAH: For following my half sister who doesn’t know I exist simply to stir the pot because I hate my biological father.

Her father hides her existence from his other daughters. Now she wants to follow her 18-year-old half sister online to shake things up. Would that be wrong?

2 min 0
WIBTAH: For following my half sister who doesn’t know I exist simply to stir the pot because I hate my biological father.

She is 30, has a job, a degree and a half sister who has no idea she exists. Her biological father has kept her a secret for years, and now she is tempted to make herself known in a way she openly admits is meant to shake things up and force the truth into the open.

WIBTAH: For following my half sister who doesn’t know I exist simply to stir the pot because I hate my biological father. - DISCLAIMER: yes I want to stir the pot bc I hate him. But at the core of it I want them to know I exist and I’m here and want to know them. It’s a complicated feeling. I know this reads as angry. I am. But it’s more than that. I don’t want to traumatize anyone but also feel like how the hell is my existence traumatizing? Is that just my anger talking or is it actually traumatizing to learn that at 18. Me 30 have a half sister who is 18. She is raised in a highly sheltered christian household.
The only social media she has is Pinterest and she is very active. My biological weird as fck father refuses to tell his two daughters that I exist. One 18 one 16. He says it will be hard on them and they wouldn’t understand. Last time I talked to him he continued to take the approach he took when I was a teen, that we need a trial run for me to know his now adult and teenage kids…. Yall would think Im a criminal or something… nope. Normal person. Have a job and degree. No criminal record. I’ve talked to him maybe 3 times sense he left when I was 2.

She has only spoken to her father a handful of times since he left when she was a toddler. His reasons for keeping her hidden have not changed, and her frustration has been building for a long time.

And honestly I’m just a bit p**sed off. Yea I should probably talk to a therapist about it. But I am literally dying to follower her on Pinterest with my name being the same last name as her and stirring the pot. Like fck you. Why should you be allowed to hide me after you’ve done nothing for me my whole life. Is this selfish and mean? I am an adult and this is childish but at the same time, I want to make them know I exist so so badly. Please don’t tell me to go to therapy, I know, just really want to know how fcked up it is for me to stir the pot like this in this way.

She knows the idea sounds petty, and she is not afraid to say so. But she adds one important detail at the end that shows there is more than anger behind her wish to be seen.

Edit: I do want a relationship with her. Not only doing this to punish him. I wouldn’t reject or be cruel to her ever.

So, Would She Be Wrong to Do It?

Her anger at a father who walked away and still hides her is completely understandable, and her half sisters arguably deserve to know she exists. But a move designed to stir the pot could hurt the very sister she hopes to know. Redditors were sympathetic to her pain, yet many felt she would be in the wrong if it was mostly about getting back at him, and urged a calmer approach. What would you do? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Life_Part_6350 on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *