AITA for insisting that my mother take back a birthday gift I found to be thoughtless, insulting, and burdensome?

His mother sent him a balance board for his birthday, and he told her it was insulting and demanded she take it back. Was he wrong to be so blunt?

2 min 0
AITA for insisting that my mother take back a birthday gift I found to be thoughtless, insulting, and burdensome?

Birthday gifts from parents can be sweet, awkward or downright baffling. For one 37-year-old man going through a rough year, his mother’s latest present felt like a pointed message rather than a kind gesture. He told her to take it back. But did honesty cross the line into cruelty, and was his reaction really about the gift at all?

AITA for insisting that my mother take back a birthday gift I found to be thoughtless, insulting, and burdensome? - I'm a 37 yo single man living alone in a modest downtown apartment. My interests are very focused on video games and other nerdy pursuits. I'm obese and out of shape. Not morbidly so, but certainly enough to be self-conscious about it. I was laid off this last summer, and will likely need to move and downsize in the next couple of years as my savings dwindle. For my birthday this week my mom sent me a gift of a Gibbon Slackboard. It's basically a self contained piece of slackline
equipment for balance and core strength training. My mom has a long history of not really knowing me well and sending me gifts that I don't particularly care for, and I've always just gritted my teeth and given my polite thanks. I found this just egregiously thoughtless though, and I told her she would be taking it back with her next time she visited. I said that I know she only meant well, and I appreciated the attempt, but that the impact is the opposite of a gift. Sending me a a piece of workout equipment completely unsolicited is insulting, and it's large enough that it's not a simple matter for me to store it or dispose of it.

He had swallowed his frustration over unwanted gifts for years. This time, though, something snapped, and what he said to his mother next would launch hundreds of strangers into a heated debate.

Now I face spending my birthday after a pretty s**tty year having to deal with not only what I'm going to do with this large, unwanted and insulting gift, but also manage my mom's emotions over my rejection of it, and I just can't. AITA for telling it straight here? Or should I have sucked it up dealt with it on my own? EDIT to clarify some frequent questions and inferences at the top level: Please don't try to diagnose my mother. We have our issues, but I'm fully willing to believe that she just didn't think through what she was sending me rather than accuse her of any sort of maliciousness.

With his feelings out in the open, he turned to Reddit for a reality check. The replies poured in so quickly and so fiercely that he felt the need to add an edit clearing up a few assumptions.

No, this is not weird reverse psychological advertising. I just wanted to be fair to my mom and note exactly what she sent. I'm sure that if I had left it more vague people would have asked exactly what it was anyway, and was trying to get ahead of that. Sorry if I stumbled into a rules violation. :( It's to be expected, but the notion that my weight issues are just because I'm sitting around all day playing video games, or otherwise don't care about my health is just patently false. It's a complex problem that I'm working on, and the gift is unhelpful for the actual issue at hand.

The comments kept digging into his weight, his hobbies and his habits. He decided to push back on the parts he felt were unfair, especially the guesses about his job and his finances.

I'm finding the inferences being drawn from my employment situation to be very interesting. Working hard for 14 years and responsibly setting aside a comfortable year or two worth of savings is irrelevant compared to 6 months of unemployment as AI is decimating the entire tech labor market. I'm fine financially. I was literally just saying that I may have to downsize so the size of the gift is noteworthy. Storage space is at a premium. That includes under couches and beds. Yes, I'm depressed, obviously. As fine as I am financially, losing my job and not quickly finding a new one is frustrating to say the least. I think the question becomes: Does my, hopefully

Then he opened up about the harder part: the emotional weight he was carrying. He asked a question that many readers found surprisingly honest, about whether a bad year excuses being blunt.

understandable, mental health state give me more reason to be firm with people making it worse? I know I was forgoing manners. I was prioritizing expressing how hurtful I found it. Yes, I'm ungrateful. From my perspective it was a white elephant gift in the original sense and I literally would have preferred she didn't send me anything. I know I can't be considered an a**hole for how it made me feel. I'm allowed to have an emotional reaction to something I find hurtful. I'm willing to be wrong about what I actually said to her though, and whether I should have spared her feelings. EDIT2 to clarify one more thing:

Even after explaining himself, people kept describing his reaction as a tantrum. So he did something unusual and shared the exact exchange between him and his mother, word for word.

People have characterized my response as a tantrum, hissy fit, berating her, etc, and it feels like you're reading a lot more into my response than actually happened. So here's what literally happened, and if you still want to characterize it that way so be it: She has told me it's been delivered and is waiting for my response after going to grab it from the mail room. I text her: "Mom... You're taking that back with you next time you visit." She texts back: "I was thinking you'd like it" then "maybe try it out"
I text back "I have plenty of workout equipment and am potentially needing to downsize in the next year or two. Also, the implication of getting someone workout equipment who hasn't asked for it is frustrating to say the least." "No, I will not try it out. It is insulting, space consuming junk that you should have talked to me about before sending to take up space in my house. It is the opposite of a gift, and if I didn't know you well enough to know you meant well it we would have a much bigger problem than me telling you to take it back. This is genuinely upsetting." She calls, and her tone is clearly hurt. She says something like 'I didn't think of it as workout

His first replies were firm. But his mother had not yet answered the strongest message of all, the one that would leave her calling him, clearly hurt, to try to understand.

equipment.' I say something like 'I know you don't mean anything by it, but I'm trying to tell you how it makes me feel. I don't know what else to say.' She says something like 'I don't what to say.' I say something like 'that's fine. I just need you to take it back. I love you. Goodbye.' She gives her goodbyes and we hang up. That's the extent of the situation. I'm obviously angry about it, and some of that obviously made its way into what I actually said to her. You all are still the judge of if did a good enough job of keeping my anger in check. Just laying

The phone call was short and painfully awkward. Neither of them seemed to know what to say, and the way it ended left readers divided over whether he had handled it well.

out the actual facts.

So, Was He Wrong?

It is easy to understand why a fitness gift might sting when someone is already self-conscious and struggling after a layoff. Still, calling a well-meant present insulting junk to your own mother is harsh. Redditors largely felt he was in the wrong, pointing out that the board is small and could simply be sold or donated, while some sympathized with how unwanted health gifts feel. What do you think? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Solesaver on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *