AITA for never feeling sad when my dad and his mistress had miscarriages?

3 min 847 0

Grief is supposed to bring people closer, but in my family, it only exposed how broken everything already was. When my mother got sick, I watched her fade while my father drifted further away, not just emotionally, but into the arms of another woman. What was once whispered became open, shameless, and cruel. I was nine when he introduced his mistress to the world as if she’d always belonged there, and by the time my mother passed, that woman had already moved in. They built a life on ashes, pretending their happiness wasn’t born from betrayal. When they began trying for children, I couldn’t bring myself to wish them joy. Every miscarriage, every tear, felt like justice, not tragedy. Maybe that sounds cold, but when love is stolen from you as a child, compassion doesn’t grow easily in its place.

The Child of Betrayal — Growing Up in the Shadow of My Father’s Affair and a Home Built on Lies

When My Mother Was Dying, My Father Was Falling in Love With Someone Else — and the Mistress Became His New Wife Before the Funeral Flowers Had Wilted

I Was Just a Kid When I Learned That Grief Can Be Shared Unequally — and Loyalty Can Be Buried Right Beside the Dead

The Mistress Who Tried to Become My Stepmom — and the Day I Realized I’d Never See Her as Anything but the Woman Who Replaced My Mother

They Tried for the Family They Destroyed — Countless Pregnancies, Countless Miscarriages, and Not a Single Tear Left in Me to Shed

Banished for My Honesty — Sent to Live With My Uncle Because I Refused to Cry for My Father’s Consequences

My Father Demanded Empathy, but How Could I Mourn for Children Who Would Only Remind Me of His Betrayal?

“Where’s Your Sadness?” He Asked Through His Tears — But How Do You Grieve for What You Never Wanted to Exist?

A Therapist Calls It Detachment, He Calls It Inhuman — But I Call It the Only Way I Survived Their Guilt and My Own Bitterness

Curious to hear the verdict from Reddit on this one.

Even now, years later, my father can’t understand why I feel nothing for the babies he lost. He calls me heartless, but he doesn’t see that he raised me inside the wreckage of his own choices. How do you mourn what represents everything that destroyed your family? I don’t celebrate his pain, but I won’t pretend to grieve it either. The truth is simple, I detached to survive. The same man who asked me to comfort his mistress while my mother’s memory still lingered in the house now demands sympathy for the children that never came. But some wounds are too deep to fake tenderness over. My therapist says it’s not cruelty, just emotional self-preservation, and maybe she’s right. Because you can only lose your mother once, but you can lose your respect for your father every single day after.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *