AITA for replacing the broken TV at my parents’ house without asking my older brother?

The family TV sat broken for a year, so one sibling finally bought a new one, and the eldest brother was furious he had not been asked first.

1 min 0
AITA for replacing the broken TV at my parents’ house without asking my older brother?

For almost a whole year, the television in the family living room sat dark and useless while everyone simply worked around it. Then one sibling quietly decided enough was enough and bought a brand-new set for their parents. No fanfare, no speeches, just a kind gesture. Yet that small act of generosity managed to spark an unexpected family feud.

AITA for replacing the broken TV at my parents’ house without asking my older brother? - We have had a broken TV in our parents’ living room for almost a year now. Everyone in the family knows it’s broken, but nobody has really done anything about it. We have all just been living with it and whenever someone wants to watch something, they use their phones or go to another room, So I decided to buy a new TV and have it installed. I didn’t make a big announcement about it because I wasn’t expecting any special recognition. I just felt it was something the family needed and I was in a position to take care of it because my parents always complain about
lack of money to replace and repair broken things in the house, When my older brother found out, he got upset. He said I should have spoken to him first because he’s the eldest and it should have been his responsibility to replace the TV and i know that my brother doesn’t care about anything until it affects him personally but now He felt I had made him look irresponsible in front of everyone. I tried explaining that the TV had been broken for almost a year and nobody had stepped forward to do anything about it. I told him we are family and I didn’t buy it to compete with him or take away his position. I simply wanted everyone to have a working TV

The eldest brother had not lifted a finger during all those months of blank screens. But the moment a new TV appeared on the wall, he suddenly had plenty to say about who should have bought it and why his younger sibling had crossed a line.

again. He got mad and said I should have waited or at least discussed it with him before making it happen. And now he’s upset with me and feels like that should have been his response not me, I honestly didn’t think doing something for our parents’ home would turn into an argument and lead to this, now he hisses anytime he sees me, AITA for replacing the TV without consulting my older brother first?

So, Was It Wrong to Just Fix It?

Family roles can matter, and some eldest siblings feel real pressure to be the one who provides. Even so, the brother had nearly a year to step up and never did, so his hurt pride is hard to blame on anyone else. Redditors were united in backing the poster, pointing out that nothing ever stopped the brother from buying a TV himself. Should a thoughtful gift ever need permission first? Share your verdict in the comments!

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Big-Tomatillo-9993 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *