AITA for telling my sister she’s a guest in our home and needs to drop the attitude?

She took in her heartbroken sister two days after moving into a new home, but the attitude over showers and chores pushed her to finally say something blunt.

1 min 2 0
AITA for telling my sister she’s a guest in our home and needs to drop the attitude?

Opening your door to a sibling in crisis feels like the most natural thing in the world. But when one woman and her husband welcomed her heartbroken sister into their brand-new home just two days after moving in, the gratitude they expected never quite arrived. Instead came shower disputes, eye-rolls over chores and long late-night texts, until she finally said what she was thinking.

AITA for telling my sister she’s a guest in our home and needs to drop the attitude? - My husband and I (both early 30s) recently moved into a new place. We had only been there for two days when my sister, Chloe, moved in with us. She is going through a tough time after getting out of a long-term relationship and moving back from 17 hours away, so we wanted to help her get back on her feet while she looks for a job and does DoorDash at night. However, tension has ramped up quickly because she’s been acting like she lives here permanently and giving major attitude over normal household
routines. For instance, she threw a fit about having to take a shower third on a morning when she didn't even have to leave the house until 10 AM. Then, when I simply asked her to bring our dogs inside at night, she copped a massive attitude about it. When I tried to address it and reminded her that my husband, Mark, and I are trying to get our own brand-new home established, and that she is a guest who doesn’t get preferential treatment, she sent me a massive paragraph/essay about how hard her life is right now, how she's trying, and how my comments make her feel like family isn't rooting for her.

Shower schedules and a simple request about the dogs might sound minor, but small frictions add up quickly when everyone shares one roof. So when she finally tried to talk it through with her sister, she hoped for an apology. What she got was something else entirely.

I love her and want her to get back on her feet, but I'm exhausted by the essay-long text arguments, the entitlement, and the sass when we just asked for basic cooperation in our own home. I told her that she needs to recognize she’s a guest who doesn't permanently live here, stop expecting preferential treatment, and drop the attitude. AITA?

So, Was She Wrong to Call Her Sister a Guest?

Supporting family through a breakup is generous, and her sister clearly is struggling. Still, a newly married couple setting up their first home has every right to expect basic cooperation in return. Redditors overwhelmingly sided with the poster, with many urging her to agree on a clear move-out timeline before resentment grows on both sides. Was calling her sister a guest fair, or too cold for someone at her lowest? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Money_Respect_3277 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *