AITAH for keeping the gender a secret?

An expectant mum refuses to reveal her baby's gender to anyone, and her crochet-loving mother and sister are not happy about it. Is she being unreasonable?

2 min 2 0
AITAH for keeping the gender a secret?

For most families, finding out whether a baby is a boy or a girl is cause for celebration, cakes and colour-coded balloons. One expectant mother, however, has a very personal reason for keeping the news to herself. Her decision has sparked a surprisingly heated argument with her mother, a crochet project caught in the middle, and a sister she never expected to oppose her.

AITAH for keeping the gender a secret? - I'm pregnant with my first and we should be finding out the gender in 4 weeks. I'm excited to find out which name i'll get to use and whether my guess is right because i've had a feeling for a while about the gender, but I think public announcement gender reveals are dumb, why should anyone else care what genitals my baby will have??? I'm very against gender norms and felt as a child that i was placed in a category and wasn't allowed to leave it. As a little girl who liked dinosaurs and monster trucks and worms and hated pink, being raised to fit into a category of pink and princesses felt like wearing clothes that were 3 sizes
too small. I felt like i wasn't allowed to be myself because i was told it was weird to like "boy things". So im very against doing that to my child because they don't deserve to feel that way either. I'll raise my child to be whoever they are, not whoever society tells them to be.My mom started an argument with me over it saying she'll have to make 2 baby blankets (we love to crochet), one in pink and one in blue and wait to see which one she can give me. I explained that's literally beating the whole point to death. Pick one, pink or blue, or green or brown or whatever color even! The baby doesn't have a favorite color when they're born it does not matter. Then she wanted to

Her own childhood clearly left a mark, and she is determined that her baby will never feel squeezed into a box. But her mother, an enthusiastic crocheter with her heart set on the perfect blanket, had very different ideas about what knowing really means.

An argument over yarn colours had quickly turned into a debate about how children should be raised. Feeling misunderstood, the mum-to-be turned to the one person she was sure would back her up, and that conversation did not go the way she hoped.

argue that gender roles are normal and she's not the weird one for going along with society's bs... good for you? Anyways, i complained to my sister about the argument and my sister took mom's side. I look up to my sister so that made me second guess myself...Am i the mean one if i keep the gender a secret from everyone including family? Or am i just being a people pleaser thinking that? It is my baby so like i know it's my decision regardless, but it's clearly upsetting my family and that makes me feel like im doing something wrong... AITAH?

So, Is She Wrong to Keep the Secret?

Her mother’s excitement is understandable, and grandparents often dream of the little details long before a baby arrives. Yet how much to share about her own pregnancy is entirely the expectant mother’s call. Redditors largely agreed she was not in the wrong, with many pointing out that families managed perfectly well without knowing for generations, and suggesting a neutral blanket as an easy fix. Would you keep it a secret too? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/wanderingwillow01 on r/AmItheA**hole.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *