WIBTAH If I choose not to go to thanksgiving dinner

She planned her dog's surgery around Thanksgiving at her parents' home, then her sister moved dinner so her friends could drink. Should she skip it?

2 min 0
WIBTAH If I choose not to go to thanksgiving dinner

Every family has its holiday traditions, and for one 36-year-old woman, Thanksgiving has always meant a quiet, cozy dinner at her parents’ house. This year she even planned her dog’s surgery around it so she could stay close to him. Then her older sister decided the whole celebration needed to move, and nobody thought to ask her first.

WIBTAH If I choose not to go to thanksgiving dinner - WIBTAH if I opt out of thanksgiving dinner with my family this year? I (36f) am divorced and live in my parents basement because I can’t afford to buy a home in my state on one income and every apartment or rental has pet restrictions. All of that is not super important but relevant to the story. Every year we have always done Thanksgiving at my parents house, me, my parents, my older sister and family (husband and 2 kids) and my older brother (not married). We all contribute dishes and have a nice quiet holiday. This year my sister
called my mom and said she had a couple friends who had nowhere to go, but she didn’t think they would be comfortable going to my parents house. Why you may ask? Because my parents don’t drink alcohol and ask us not to drink alcohol in their house. So my sister asked my mom if we could move thanksgiving to her house, which my mom said yes without checking with anyone else. Normally I wouldn’t have a problem with this. However I have a 1.5 year old pup that is scheduled to have a minor surgery the Wednesday before thanksgiving. I purposely scheduled it that way so I could be home with him for 4 days and monitor him to make sure he

The reason for the sudden change of venue was surprising enough. But for this dog mom, the timing could not have been worse, because she had carefully planned the entire long weekend around one very important furry patient.

doesn’t lick his stitches. My dad mentioned to me my sister wanted to change locations and I said I need to do Thanksgiving at our house this year because I can’t justify leaving my dog for hours right after he had surgery. I didn’t know it had already been decided that we were changing things. My sister cornered me at my nephews basketball game tonight and said she had already invited her friends and it would make her look like an a*s if she retracted. She offered to let me bring my dogs to her house but I really don’t feel comfortable doing that for multiple reasons: I have 2 large dogs and she has 2 small dogs who bark at all other dogs

She thought speaking up early would settle things, not realizing the decision had already been made behind her back. Her sister was not about to back down, and she came armed with what she believed was a perfect solution.

My dogs live at my parents house so it is easy to keep them settled around a lot of people. They would get excited at a new location My sister has a very nice home we lots of expensive decor and I would be nervous my dogs would get excited and break something. At my parents house I can keep them contained in the basement with their dog beds and toys and monitor them on my security camera during dinner. There is nowhere in my sister’s house to keep them contained besides a bedroom. I won’t be relaxed because I will be nervous the entire time that something will happen and then I’ll get blamed.

For a woman who knows her two big dogs well, that offer raised far more worries than it solved. And the list of reasons she was uneasy was not finished yet, nor was her patience with her sister’s guests.

I mentioned all this to my sister, but she still said her friends wouldn’t be comfortable at my parents house because they want to drink. So now I’m irritated because I’ve had this all planned out for weeks and now I’m being asked to adjust everything because these 2 people can’t give up a glass of wine for thanksgiving. I haven’t met them and I already dislike them. I do want to note this is not the first time we have been asked to change up plans to accommodate my sister. We’re all just expected to smile and say “sure whatever you need”.I even told my sister that I’m tired of always being the one who has to compromise to make her life

Every concern was laid out clearly, and still her sister would not budge. As the frustration grew, it became obvious this argument was about much more than one dinner, and years of quietly bending were about to come pouring out.

easier. She demanded examples of other times we’ve had to accommodate her, which I happily gave and she basically wrote me off, said no one else had a problem with it ( I can’t help that no one else in the family has a backbone to stand up to my sister) and I was being a b**ch. Now I’m thinking the holidays already been ruined and I should just stay home with my dogs and celebrate by myself. They can have their thanksgiving wherever the hell they want. WIBTAH?

So, Would She Be Wrong to Stay Home?

Her sister likely wanted to be a good friend by welcoming people who had nowhere else to go. But the plan was changed without asking, and her reasons for staying close to a recovering pup are practical, not petty. Redditors largely felt she was within her rights to stay home, though some suggested she simply bow out calmly rather than turn it into a bigger family fight. Would you skip the dinner or make it work? Share your verdict in the comments!

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Assattack01 on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *