AITAH for not spending the night with my bf until family member leaves?

The family friend who raised her is staying at her place and says her boyfriend can't sleep over. She wants to keep the peace, but is she wrong?

2 min 4 0
AITAH for not spending the night with my bf until family member leaves?

Six months into a happy relationship, one young woman has hit her first real conflict, and it is not about her boyfriend at all. The man who raised her after she lost a parent as a child is staying with her for a while, and he has made one request that has quietly started to strain everything.

AITAH for not spending the night with my bf until family member leaves? - My bf (30m) and I (25f) have only been official for like 6 months, so this is the first real conflict we have had. Since we started dating we have spent almost every night together. After my parent died when I was 11 I have lived with a family friend “uncle” so he raised me after that. We are very close and he has done a lot for me. Him and his gf broke up a few weeks ago. He wants to move closer to me so he has been staying with me until he finds a place where I live.

Her loyalty to the man who stepped in when she needed him most is easy to understand. But as his stay stretched on, he made a request that would test both her relationship and her sense of what she owes him.

I have obviously been spending more time with him since and less with my bf. Bf has spent a couple of nights with me and we still go out. I feel like I still prioritize him. My uncle told me he doesn’t want me to spend the night with bf while he is staying with me. It would make him uncomfortable, it would be weird to be alone, and he thinks we should be spending this time together. I don’t really know what to say or do rather than just do it for a couple of months. Uncle and I have talked about it more than once and if I bring up something we both know is true, he will just bring up one of the other points.

She has tried reasoning with him, but every conversation seems to circle back to where it began. Meanwhile, the person feeling the strain most is her boyfriend, and his patience is beginning to wear thin.

My bf is starting to get really frustrated with this. He doesn’t understand and thinks it is way overstepping. I feel like this is a small, temporary sacrifice and like religious parents would be like this for example. He has spent the night with me a couple of times but he is uncomfortable because he thinks my uncle doesn’t want him there which isn’t true. It’s driving him crazy and we have been arguing about it. He doesn’t understand where I’m coming from at all. I want to know if I’m wrong so I can deal with it. I don’t think it’s worth it to have conflict or make the person who raised me uncomfortable. I could understand if it was permanent, but it isn’t. AITAH?

So, Is She Wrong to Go Along With It?

Her gratitude toward the man who raised her is deeply touching, and wanting to keep the peace is understandable. But she is an adult in her own home, and the request has left her boyfriend feeling unwelcome. Many Redditors felt she was in the wrong for letting her uncle set the rules, warning that the arrangement could quietly damage her relationship and her independence. What would you do in her place? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Andra457 on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *