AITAH for being upset that my girlfriend finalized her birthday plans with another guy before she ever told me

He asked his girlfriend about her birthday plans, only to learn she had already booked a concert with another guy. Is he controlling for being hurt?

2 min 2 0
AITAH for being upset that my girlfriend finalized her birthday plans with another guy before she ever told me

Birthdays are supposed to be simple: celebrate the person you love. So when one boyfriend, who keeps a running list of important dates so he never forgets, asked his girlfriend about her plans, he expected to help shape the day. Instead, he discovered she had already made plans with another guy, and the argument that followed has him questioning everything.

AITAH for being upset that my girlfriend finalized her birthday plans with another guy before she ever told me - I (30M) have been dating my girlfriend for a while. Her birthday is November 18, and I keep a running notes list on my phone of important dates specifically so I never forget things like her birthday. She knows about the list. A week before her birthday, I asked her what she was doing for it. She didn't give me a straight answer. I later found out that her friend Connor had invited her to a concert that same day — a few hours before I asked — and she had already said yes and bought
her ticket. She sent me a photo of the purchase, timestamped before I knew any plan existed. She never asked me, never mentioned it, and I only found out because I happened to ask. When I told her I was hurt, she said she did invite me, that the concert doesn't start until 7:30 PM so we have the whole day together, and that she shouldn't have to apologize for wanting to spend time with both her boyfriend and her friend. She called me controlling and irrational. My issue isn't really the concert. It's that:

On its own, a concert ticket might not seem like much. But when he raised his hurt feelings, the conversation quickly turned, and he realised this was not really about one evening at all, but about a pattern he could no longer ignore.

- She locked in the plan with him first and I was an afterthought. - Connor is the same friend she previously went camping with one-on-one, which I already told her felt weird to me. - On my birthday this year, she forgot plans we had and left me to go to a concert with a friend, saying the tickets were already bought — so this feels like a repeat. - A few months ago I caught her flirting with another guy over text. She apologized, said it was a one-time mistake, and I stayed, but the trust has been shaky since.

With every point on his list, the picture grew more complicated, and a little history went a long way toward explaining his unease. Still, his girlfriend was firm that he was the one being unreasonable, which left him with an uncomfortable choice.

I don't even like the band, so my choices are apparently to pay to tag along on his plan for her birthday, or not be there. I don't think asking to be consulted before she commits to birthday plans with another guy is controlling, but she's convinced I'm the problem here. AITA for being upset about this? Edit: Well, s**t, this is a lot of replies I reached out to this guy, he's literally autistic(not as a joke or anything), and it was clear he is a bit odd. Actually we made plans to hang out.. however, this is something I could have been told off the rip then just talked to the guy yet she was being cagey. We have been dating since early July to those asking

Plenty of people had opinions once the story hit Reddit. But the poster soon returned with an edit that changed the picture once again, revealing a surprising conversation with Connor and some new details about the people involved.

I didn't realize it mattered Connor has a girlfriend to some, interestingly this girlfriend is my girlfriend's ex who cheated on Connor is my understanding. More context I told her that we should just post it all to reddit, I didn't, she ended up doing it first then deleting it on this sub, didn't mention she has cheated before, so I said I bet the replies would be very different if all the details were included. Then made a post before going to bed.

So, Was He Wrong to Be Upset?

Wanting to celebrate with friends is normal, and his girlfriend insists he is invited. But being told after plans are locked in, with past trust issues still unresolved, understandably stung. Redditors mostly felt his hurt was valid, though reactions were mixed, and many wondered whether the bigger question was the health of the relationship itself rather than a single concert. Was he being controlling or reasonable? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Stewartmanbro on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *