AITAH for not wanting my 3month old playing Jesus in a church play?

Her in-laws volunteered her newborn to play baby Jesus in their church Christmas play without asking. When she said no, they went quiet. Was she wrong?

2 min 1 0
AITAH for not wanting my 3month old playing Jesus in a church play?

Grandparents showing off a new grandchild is nothing unusual. But one new mother was stunned when her in-laws volunteered her, her husband and their newborn son to star as Mary, Joseph and baby Jesus in their church Christmas play. Her careful answer was met with silence, and now she is wondering whether protecting her baby has made her the villain.

AITAH for not wanting my 3month old playing Jesus in a church play? - Context to add bc people think Im being selfish about my 2 month old who isnt even 3 months yet.... He gets is vaccines today. I was just going to see if he felt OK before I tale him to a baby shower. If not then I was going to tell them they could watch him this Saturday(tomorrow). They have asked since he was born. I have bad anxiety about it and think its my hormones . So was going to dip my toe in the water and let them watch him at our house for a few hours. Now, I am not sure I want to do that. They have come every single week since he was born.

Before the main story even begins, it is clear she has been sensitive to suggestions that she is keeping her in-laws away. As she explains, the grandparents have been ever-present since the birth, and lately something about their reactions has started to bother her.

I am not keeping them from their grandkid* Hi, 33F and my husband 35M have been dealing with his parents (75M and 75 F) a lot since I gave birth to our son in September. This is their first and only grandchild as my husband is an only child. They have been quite a lot, but in a loving way I guess. Recently, I have noticed that when I send any text that tells them no, or sets a boundary, I do not get responded to. For context, this is sometimes in a group chat with my husband and sometimes not. Every year for their church they are a part of a Christmas "program", as they call it. Its just a play and they change up
scenes/themes, but its basically the same thing every year. Towards the end there is a part where they all sing a song about Jesus and walk down the aisles. On the stage the song ends with Joseph, Mary, and baby Jesus sitting by a manger. Every year for the last 5 years they have had a doll for Jesus. Well....this year, for who knows why, his parents volunteered us to be Joseph and Mary, and our son play baby Jesus....when this was brought up in person my husband and I just kind of awkwardly laughed about it. One, because being in a play is both our worst nightmare. Two, because our son would only have just turned 3months a few days before.

The annual programme sounds like a charming community tradition, exactly the kind of thing doting grandparents love to be part of. But this year, the couple were about to learn, the grandparents had quietly decided the show needed a very real, very tiny addition.

We were not exactly happy about the idea, but both agreed that if I didn't work we would do it. This is mainly bc I dont want some random "Mary" holding my 3month old child. Especially because it will be flu/covid season. Anyway, this ask kind of got put on a back burner. They never gave us a date or really brought it back up. Well, yesterday my FIL messaged both my husband and I asking if we were still available for both the 1pm and 7pm show, and then gave us the date. Of course, its on a Saturday that I am working. I just used all my PTO for maternity leave...so can't do much there.

The couple quietly reached an agreement between themselves and assumed the topic had faded. Then a message arrived with dates, times and a clear expectation, and the new mum had to decide how to respond.

I messaged my husband to say that I would respond with what we agreed upon. Looking back now, I kind of wished he was the one to say it. I just stated that I would be working and do not feel super comfortable with someone I dont know holding our infant. Esp during the sick season. As you can probably guess my message was ignored. Today I decided to ask MIL if FIL got my text and then reminded them I may have them watch our son this Saturday, they have been wanting to watch him. Its not the Saturday of the play in Dec. (Context: I will be at a baby shower and husband is hunting that day) She responded with "yes he read it.

That short reply, after days of silence, felt loaded with meaning. As she read it over again, the new mother found herself replaying every message and wondering whether one simple answer about her own baby had quietly cost the family its peace.

Ok." It was clearly a short tone and I knew they were upset. Am I being unreasonable? Lol. I wouldn't think this was such a big deal...but also I feel like they really just wanted to "show off" their grandson...why does he need to be in this play? We never gave them a response if we would do it or not. We only discussed amongst ourselves. So I dont really get why there was a sour response bc they just assumed. Our child is not a pawn or toy to be used whenever they feel like it...seems selfish. So, AITAH for saying what I said? TLDR: I believe my inlaws are mad that I dont want our infant son to be in a Christmas play.
Where he would be held and carried by a random person I dont know during flu/covid season. All while I'll be at work.

So, Was She Wrong to Say No to the Play?

Her in-laws are clearly besotted with their only grandchild, and their excitement comes from a loving place. But volunteering a newborn for two shows during cold and flu season, without asking, put the new parents in an awkward spot. Redditors broadly sided with the mother, though many felt her husband should have been the one to answer his parents, and that a firm no at the start would have spared everyone. Was she right? Share your verdict in the comments.

Source: This story was originally shared by u/Alert_Usual1197 on r/AITAH.

How did this make you feel?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *